This article reflects federal rules as of June 2026 and covers tax year 2025 and the 2026 filing season. Section 1035 is a permanent part of the Internal Revenue Code, not a temporary 2025-law (OBBBA) provision. State rules vary — most states follow the federal treatment, but confirm your state’s conformity and current figures before you act.
Quick Answer
Yes. For tax year 2025, you can move the cash value of an old life insurance policy into a non-qualified annuity tax-free using a Section 1035 exchange. The insurers must transfer the money directly, the owner must stay the same, and any cash or loan payoff you pocket is taxed.
This matters because a swap that looks “tax-free” can quietly become a tax bill. If you cancel the old policy and take the check yourself, or if an old policy loan gets wiped out in the deal, the IRS treats part of the move as ordinary income — at your regular tax rate, not the lower capital-gains rate.
The stakes are real and the timing is tight. A failed exchange is taxed in the year it happens, you can owe a 10% penalty if you are under age 59½, and the insurer reports the whole event to the IRS on a Form 1099-R. Roughly 1 in 5 American households owns an annuity, according to LIMRA industry data, so the choices you make here ripple into a large share of retirement plans.
Here is what you will learn:
- 💡 How a 1035 exchange lets old life insurance become an annuity without an instant tax bill
- ⚠️ Why an outstanding policy loan is the #1 trap that turns “tax-free” into taxable
- 🔁 The one-way rule: life can become an annuity, but an annuity can never become life insurance tax-free
- 🧮 Worked dollar examples showing cost basis, the exclusion ratio, and tax actually saved
- 🗂️ The exact steps, forms, deadlines, and mistakes to avoid before you sign anything
What a 1035 Exchange Actually Is
A 1035 exchange is a direct swap of one insurance-based contract for another that the tax code lets you make without paying tax on the built-up gain. The name comes from Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code, which says “no gain or loss shall be recognized” when you trade qualifying contracts. In plain words, the gain inside your old policy does not vanish and it is not forgiven — it simply rides along into the new contract, untaxed for now.
Think of it like rolling the equity from one house straight into the next without cashing out. You never touch the money, so there is no taxable event. The cash value leaves the old life insurer and lands at the new annuity company through a paper transfer you authorize but never personally receive.
Why does this rule exist? Without it, anyone who wanted a better-suited product would have to surrender the old one, pay tax on every dollar of gain, and start over with less money. Congress created Section 1035 so people could fix or upgrade an aging policy without a tax penalty blocking the door. The consequence of not using it is steep: surrender an old policy outright and the entire gain becomes ordinary income that year.
A common misconception is that “tax-free” means “tax-gone.” It does not. The gain is deferred, not erased. You will owe income tax on it later when you eventually pull money out of the annuity. What you should do about this is simple — treat the exchange as a way to delay and reshape the tax, not to dodge it forever, and plan for the tax that arrives when income payments begin.
The “Like-Kind” Ladder: What Can Become What
Section 1035 only blesses certain trades, and the direction matters more than almost anything else. The code sorts contracts into a one-way ladder, and you can move down the ladder but never back up. The three rungs, in order, are life insurance, then endowment contracts, then annuities.
The statute and IRS guidance allow these tax-free moves:
- Life insurance → another life insurance policy, an endowment, an annuity, or a qualified long-term care contract
- Endowment → another endowment or an annuity
- Annuity → another annuity or a qualified long-term care contract
- Long-term care → another long-term care contract
The single most important restriction is this: you can turn life insurance into an annuity, but you can never turn an annuity into life insurance tax-free. The reason is that an annuity holds taxable gain, while a life insurance death benefit usually passes income-tax-free. Congress blocked that move so people could not launder taxable annuity gains into a tax-free death benefit. Try it anyway and the IRS treats it as a full surrender, taxing every dollar of annuity gain as ordinary income.
A common misconception is that “like-kind” means you can swap freely in any direction the way some property exchanges work. Here it does not — the ladder is strict and one-way. What you should do about it: confirm in writing that your specific move (life → annuity) is on the permitted list before you sign, because reversing course later is not an option.
Why People Turn Old Life Insurance Into an Annuity
The reason this move is so popular is that an old life insurance policy and a retirement annuity solve very different problems. Life insurance protects people who depend on your income. An annuity, by contrast, turns a lump of cash value into a stream of income you cannot outlive. As priorities shift from “protect my family if I die young” to “fund my own retirement,” the old policy can become the wrong tool.
Several life events push people toward this swap. The kids are grown and self-supporting, so the death benefit matters less. The mortgage is paid, removing the debt the policy once covered. A universal life policy is underperforming, with rising internal costs eating the cash value. Or the premiums have simply become a strain on a fixed retirement income.
The consequence of holding the wrong product is quiet but costly: you keep paying for protection you no longer need while missing the guaranteed income an annuity could provide. A common misconception is that you must surrender the old policy and “take the loss” to escape it. You do not — the 1035 exchange lets you redeploy that cash value into income without a tax hit on the way. What you should do is run the numbers on both paths before deciding, because the death benefit you give up is gone for good.
How the Tax Math Works: Basis, Gain, and the Exclusion Ratio
To understand the tax, you need three plain-English terms. Cost basis is the total of the premiums you paid into the old policy. Gain is the cash value minus that basis. The exclusion ratio is the slice of each future annuity payment that comes back to you tax-free because it represents your own returned principal.
In a valid 1035 exchange, your old cost basis carries over to the new annuity. This is a major benefit. Per IRS rules under Section 1035, the deferred gain stays inside the new contract and your original investment amount is preserved. That carried-over basis later shrinks the taxable portion of your income payments.
Here is the consequence of getting basis wrong: if an exchange fails, the new contract’s basis resets to its fair market value, and the old gain is taxed right away as ordinary income. A common misconception is that the gain is taxed as a long-term capital gain at favorable rates. It is not — insurance and annuity gain is always taxed as ordinary income at your marginal rate. What you should do: ask both insurers, in writing, to confirm the cost basis being carried into the new annuity, and keep that figure with your tax records.
Worked Example: Carrying Basis Into the Annuity
Suppose Maria, age 62, owns a universal life policy with a cash value of $90,000 and a cost basis (total premiums paid) of $40,000. Her gain is $50,000. She does a clean 1035 exchange into a non-qualified income annuity.
No tax is due at the exchange. The full $90,000 moves over, and her $40,000 basis carries with it. When she later annuitizes and the contract is expected to pay out $150,000 over her lifetime, her exclusion ratio is roughly $40,000 ÷ $150,000, or about 27%. So about 27% of each payment returns tax-free, and the remaining 73% is taxable ordinary income — until she has recovered her full basis. That carried-over basis is what keeps part of every check out of the IRS’s reach.
The Policy-Loan Trap: How “Tax-Free” Becomes Taxable
The biggest hidden danger is an outstanding loan against the old life insurance policy. If you borrowed against the cash value and that loan is paid off or wiped out during the exchange, the IRS treats the loan payoff as “boot” — cash you effectively received. Per federal boot rules tied to Section 1031 and IRS analysis of failed exchanges, boot is taxable up to the amount of gain in the contract.
The consequence is a surprise tax bill on a move you thought was tax-free. A common misconception is that because no cash hit your bank account, nothing is taxable. Wrong — debt forgiveness counts as a distribution. What you should do about it: pay the loan off before the exchange, or carry the loan over to the new contract if the new insurer allows it, so the loan is never “extinguished” in the swap.
Worked Example: The Loan That Triggered Tax
David, age 65, has a whole life policy with $80,000 of cash value, a $30,000 basis, and a $15,000 outstanding loan. His gain is $50,000. He 1035-exchanges the net $65,000 into an annuity, and the $15,000 loan is paid off in the process.
Because his gain ($50,000) exceeds the loan payoff ($15,000), the entire $15,000 is taxed as ordinary income that year. If David is in the 22% federal bracket, that is about $3,300 in federal tax he did not expect. Had he repaid the $15,000 loan from savings first, the exchange would have been fully tax-free.
Which Situation Applies to You?
The right answer depends on your facts. Use this quick guide to find the part of the article that fits you.
- You own a paid-up or underperforming policy and want lifetime income → the exchange usually fits; focus on the basis and exclusion-ratio sections.
- You have an outstanding policy loan → stop and read the loan-trap section first; repay or carry the loan before exchanging.
- You are under age 59½ → a failed exchange adds a 10% penalty; the clean direct-transfer rules matter most for you.
- You still need a death benefit for dependents → reconsider; giving up the death benefit may outweigh the income gain.
- You own an annuity and want life insurance → this move is never tax-free; read the one-way ladder section.
Three Common Scenarios and Their Tax Outcomes
These three patterns cover most readers searching this topic. Each is shown as the choice you make and the tax result that follows.
| What You Do | What the IRS Does |
|---|---|
| Direct insurer-to-insurer transfer of cash value, same owner, no loan | No tax now; basis carries over; gain deferred inside the annuity |
| You surrender the policy, take the check, then buy an annuity yourself | Full gain taxed as ordinary income this year; deferral is lost |
| Exchange a policy that still has a $15,000 loan paid off in the deal | $15,000 taxed as ordinary income (up to the gain) as “boot” |
A second comparison readers ask about is the direction of the move and whether the tax code allows it.
| Move You Want to Make | Is It Tax-Free? |
|---|---|
| Old life insurance → non-qualified annuity | Yes, if rules are met |
| Annuity → new life insurance policy | No — never permitted tax-free |
| Life insurance → qualified long-term care contract | Yes, permitted since the 2006 Pension Protection Act |
A third scenario set covers age and timing, which changes the penalty picture.
| Your Age and Action | Penalty Result |
|---|---|
| Age 62, clean 1035 exchange, no cash out | No tax, no penalty |
| Age 55, failed exchange creates taxable gain | Ordinary income tax plus 10% early-withdrawal penalty |
| Age 60, valid exchange but receives $5,000 cash boot | $5,000 taxed; no penalty if over 59½ |
Named Examples: How It Plays Out
Carlos, age 67 — the clean swap. Carlos owns a $120,000 cash-value universal life policy with a $70,000 basis and no loan. His children are grown, so he no longer needs the death benefit. He files a direct 1035 exchange into a fixed income annuity. No tax is due, his $70,000 basis carries over, and he now receives monthly income with part of each check tax-free under the exclusion ratio.
Linda, age 58 — the costly shortcut. Linda surrenders her $60,000 policy (basis $25,000), deposits the check, and buys an annuity a week later. Because she took personal possession of the funds, the IRS treats it as a surrender plus a new purchase. Her $35,000 gain is taxed as ordinary income, and because she is under 59½, she also owes a 10% penalty on the taxable amount.
Robert, age 70 — the long-term care pivot. Robert no longer needs life insurance but worries about future care costs. He 1035-exchanges his $100,000 cash-value policy into a qualified long-term care contract, a move allowed since the 2006 Pension Protection Act. The exchange is tax-free, and qualified care benefits later come out tax-free too.
Step-by-Step: How to Do the Exchange Right
Doing this correctly is mostly about paperwork and sequence. Follow these steps in order.
- Confirm your move is allowed (life → annuity is fine; annuity → life is not) and that your old policy has cash value, since a policy with no cash value cannot be exchanged.
- Clear or plan for any policy loan — repay it from savings or arrange to carry it to the new contract so it is not extinguished in the swap.
- Choose the new annuity and open the contract with the same owner and same insured/annuitant as the old policy; any change in owner or insured disqualifies the exchange.
- Sign the new insurer’s 1035 exchange request form, which authorizes a direct insurer-to-insurer transfer — never let the funds pass through your hands.
- Let the companies transfer the cash value directly; the old insurer sends the money to the new one.
- Keep all confirmation documents and the basis figure for your records.
The whole process typically takes two to six weeks. The cost of a DIY exchange is usually just the time and any surrender charges on the old policy; a fee-only advisor or CPA review might run a few hundred dollars and is worth it if a loan or large gain is involved. There is no IRS filing you must submit for a valid exchange — the insurer reports it on Form 1099-R, often with a code showing it was a tax-free 1035 exchange.
Mistakes to Avoid
Each of these errors carries a real cost. Avoid all of them.
- Taking the check yourself. Receiving the funds personally turns the swap into a taxable surrender, taxing the entire gain as ordinary income.
- Ignoring a policy loan. A loan paid off in the exchange is taxable “boot” up to the amount of gain — a surprise bill.
- Changing the owner or insured. A different owner or annuitant on the new contract disqualifies the exchange and triggers full tax.
- Trying to go annuity → life insurance. This is never tax-free; it forces immediate tax on all annuity gain.
- Exchanging a policy with no cash value. With nothing to transfer, there is no valid 1035 exchange and no basis to preserve.
- Forgetting the 10% penalty under 59½. A failed exchange for a younger owner adds a 10% early-withdrawal penalty on top of income tax.
- Assuming the gain is gone forever. The gain is only deferred; it is taxed as ordinary income when you withdraw or annuitize.
- Surrendering before the new contract is ready. A gap can break the direct-transfer requirement and create a taxable event.
Do’s and Don’ts
Do:
- Do insist on a direct insurer-to-insurer transfer, because touching the money breaks the tax-free treatment.
- Do repay or carry over any policy loan first, because an extinguished loan is taxable boot.
- Do keep the same owner and insured, because any change disqualifies the exchange.
- Do get the carried-over cost basis confirmed in writing, because it controls your future tax.
- Do compare the death benefit you lose against the income you gain, because that benefit cannot be recovered.
Don’t:
- Don’t surrender the old policy and rebuy on your own, because that is a taxable sale, not an exchange.
- Don’t assume “tax-free” means no tax ever, because the gain is only deferred.
- Don’t exchange just to chase a sales pitch, because a new contract may carry fresh surrender charges.
- Don’t ignore state conformity, because a few states may treat the move differently.
- Don’t skip professional advice when a loan or large gain is involved, because one misstep can cost thousands.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Defers tax on built-up gain, because Section 1035 recognizes no gain at the exchange.
- Carries over your cost basis, because that lowers the taxable share of future income.
- Converts dead death benefit into lifetime income, because an annuity pays you while you live.
- Stops unwanted premiums, because the annuity is funded by existing cash value.
- Can fund long-term care tax-free, because life-to-LTC exchanges are permitted.
Cons:
- You permanently lose the death benefit, because the life policy is gone.
- The deferred gain is still taxed later, because deferral is not forgiveness.
- New surrender charges may apply, because the annuity starts a fresh schedule.
- A loan can trigger surprise tax, because loan payoff is boot.
- Annuity income is taxed as ordinary income, because it does not get capital-gains rates.
Federal vs. State Treatment
The federal rule is settled: a valid 1035 exchange creates no taxable income on the gain. State income tax treatment generally follows the federal rule, because most states start from federal taxable income. That said, conformity is not guaranteed, and a handful of states have their own quirks or do not automatically adopt every federal provision.
| Level | Treatment of a Valid Life-to-Annuity Exchange |
|---|---|
| Federal | No gain recognized; basis carries over; gain deferred |
| Most states | Follow federal — no state tax at the exchange |
| No-income-tax states (e.g., Florida, Texas) | No state income tax applies to the gain regardless |
The consequence of assuming your state conforms when it does not is a state tax bill you did not budget for. A common misconception is that “tax-free” is automatically tax-free in every state. What you should do: check your state’s department of revenue guidance or ask a local CPA whether your state conforms to Section 1035 before you act.
What to Do Next
Take these steps in order before you sign anything.
- Pull your old policy’s current cash value, cost basis, and any outstanding loan balance from the issuing insurer.
- Decide whether you truly no longer need the death benefit; if dependents rely on it, reconsider.
- Repay any policy loan from other funds, or confirm the new insurer will carry it over.
- Choose the new annuity and complete its 1035 exchange form so the transfer is direct, keeping the same owner and insured.
- Gather records: the confirmation of basis, the exchange paperwork, and the Form 1099-R the insurer issues.
- Call a CPA or tax attorney if you have a loan, a large gain, are under 59½, or are unsure your state conforms — this is exactly when professional help (often a few hundred dollars) prevents a four-figure mistake.
This article is educational and is not a substitute for advice from a licensed CPA, tax attorney, or financial professional for your specific situation. Section 1035 is settled law, but loans, age, and state rules add real complexity — a short professional review before you exchange is well worth it.
FAQs
Can you turn old life insurance into an annuity tax-free?
Yes. For tax year 2025, a Section 1035 exchange lets you move life insurance cash value into a non-qualified annuity with no tax now, as long as the transfer is direct, the owner stays the same, and you take no cash out.
Can you exchange an annuity for life insurance tax-free?
No. This move is never permitted tax-free. The tax code blocks it to stop people from converting taxable annuity gains into a tax-free death benefit, and attempting it makes the full gain taxable as ordinary income.
Is the gain in a 1035 exchange ever taxed?
Yes, later. The gain is deferred, not erased. You owe ordinary income tax on it when you withdraw money or receive annuity payments above your cost basis — it is not forgiven by the exchange.
What is “boot” in a 1035 exchange?
Cash or loan payoff you effectively receive. Boot is taxable up to the amount of gain in the contract. An outstanding policy loan wiped out in the exchange is the most common form of boot.
Does an outstanding policy loan make the exchange taxable?
Yes, usually. If the loan is paid off during the exchange, that payoff is taxed as ordinary income up to your gain. Repay the loan first or carry it to the new contract to avoid the tax.
What form reports a 1035 exchange?
Form 1099-R. The insurer that issued the old contract reports the exchange to you and the IRS, typically with a distribution code showing it was a tax-free Section 1035 exchange.
Is there a penalty if I am under age 59½?
Yes, on a failed exchange. A valid exchange has no penalty. But if the exchange fails and creates taxable gain, the IRS adds a 10% early-withdrawal penalty on the taxable amount for owners under 59½.
What is the exclusion ratio?
The tax-free share of each annuity payment. It equals your cost basis divided by the expected total payout. That percentage of every payment returns tax-free as your own principal until your basis is fully recovered.
Can I receive the funds and reinvest them myself?
No. Taking the money personally turns the exchange into a taxable surrender and a new purchase. The funds must move directly from the old insurer to the new one to keep tax-free treatment.
Does my state tax a 1035 exchange?
Usually not. Most states follow the federal rule and impose no tax on a valid exchange. A few states may differ, so confirm with your state’s department of revenue or a local CPA before acting.
Can I exchange life insurance for long-term care coverage?
Yes. Since the 2006 Pension Protection Act, you can do a tax-free 1035 exchange from life insurance or a non-qualified annuity into a qualified long-term care insurance contract.
Does the policy need cash value to qualify?
Yes. A 1035 exchange requires a contract with cash value to transfer. A term policy or any policy with no cash value has nothing to exchange and cannot preserve basis in a new contract.
This article reflects federal rules as of June 2026 and covers tax year 2025 and the 2026 filing season. Tax law changes — confirm current figures and your state’s conformity before you file or exchange.
Related reading
- Can You Move an Existing Policy Into an ILIT? (w/Examples) + FAQs
- Can You 1035 Exchange a Policy That Has a Loan? (w/Examples) + FAQs
- Can You 1035 Exchange an Annuity Into Life Insurance? (w/Examples) + FAQs
- Can You 1035 Exchange Life Insurance Into an Annuity? (w/Examples) + FAQs
- Does a 1035 Exchange Require the Same Owner and Insured? (w/Examples) + FAQs
- Should You 1035 a Cash-Value Policy You No Longer Need? (w/Examples) + FAQs