When a corporation pays its owners, the answer to whether it generates a Form 1099 is simple: no for an S-Corporation profit distribution and yes for a C-Corporation profit distribution. An S-Corp uses Schedule K-1 to report profit distributions, while a C-Corp uses Form 1099-DIV. This distinction seems minor, but it is the tip of an iceberg hiding two completely different tax philosophies.
The core problem for business owners arises from a direct conflict created by the Internal Revenue Code. For S-Corporations, IRC § 162(a)(1) demands that shareholder-employees be paid a “reasonable salary” for their work, which is subject to a 15.3% payroll tax. This rule directly clashes with the owner’s powerful incentive to minimize that salary and take more money as a payroll-tax-free distribution.
This conflict is not theoretical; studies have estimated that S-Corporations underreport their owners’ reasonable compensation by as much as 38%, creating a massive red flag for the IRS. Getting this wrong can lead the IRS to reclassify your distributions as wages, resulting in a crushing bill for back taxes, penalties, and interest.
Here is what you will learn to avoid that fate:
- 💰 The fundamental tax difference between an S-Corp “distribution” and a C-Corp “dividend,” and why one triggers a Form 1099-DIV while the other uses a Schedule K-1.
- ⚖️ How to navigate the “Reasonable Compensation” minefield for S-Corps, solving the conflict between salary and distributions to stay off the IRS’s radar.
- 📉 The critical role of “Shareholder Basis” in S-Corps and how a tax-free distribution can suddenly become a taxable capital gain if you mismanage it.
- 🔍 A line-by-line breakdown of Form 1099-DIV and Schedule K-1, demystifying the key boxes so you know exactly what they mean for your personal tax return.
- ❌ How to avoid the most common and costly mistakes, from making disproportionate distributions to misclassifying shareholder loans, that could jeopardize your S-Corp status.
Deconstructing the Corporate Payout: The Two Worlds of Shareholder Payments
To understand shareholder payments, you must first see that S-Corporations and C-Corporations live in separate universes governed by different laws of tax physics. An S-Corporation is a pass-through entity, meaning it doesn’t pay corporate income tax. Instead, all profits and losses are “passed through” directly to the owners’ personal tax returns each year, where they are taxed.
A C-Corporation is a separate taxable entity. It pays its own income tax at the corporate level. When it later distributes its after-tax profits to shareholders, those owners pay tax on that money again on their personal returns. This is the infamous concept of double taxation.
These two structures create four key terms you must master:
- Salary: This is payment for work performed. It is a business expense for both S-Corps and C-Corps, reported on a Form W-2, and is subject to payroll taxes (Social Security and Medicare).
- S-Corp Distribution: This is a payout of company profits to an S-Corp owner. It is generally not subject to payroll taxes and is reported on a Schedule K-1.
- C-Corp Dividend: This is a payout of a C-Corp’s after-tax profits to a shareholder. It is not subject to payroll taxes but is the second layer in double taxation, reported on a Form 1099-DIV.
- Shareholder Basis: This is the shareholder’s total investment in an S-Corporation. It is the key metric that determines if a distribution is tax-free or not.
The relationship is simple: the tax structure of the entity dictates the tax form used. S-Corps pass profits through, so the distribution itself isn’t the main taxable event; the K-1 tracks it. C-Corps create a second taxable event with dividends, so the IRS requires the 1099-DIV to track that specific income.
The S-Corporation Tightrope: Balancing Salary and Distributions
For any S-Corp owner who also works in the business, the most dangerous and important concept to master is reasonable compensation. Because S-Corp distributions are free from the 15.3% FICA payroll tax, there is a massive incentive to pay yourself a tiny salary (like $1) and take all the company’s profits as a distribution to save thousands in taxes.
The IRS is acutely aware of this strategy and considers it a tax avoidance maneuver. To combat it, the IRS requires S-Corporations to pay shareholder-employees a salary that is reasonable for the services they provide before any distributions are taken. The consequence for failing this test is severe: the IRS can reclassify your tax-advantaged distributions as wages and demand all the back payroll taxes, plus penalties and interest.
What Does the IRS Consider “Reasonable?”
There is no magic number or simple 60/40 rule, despite what you may hear. The IRS and Tax Courts look at a combination of factors to determine if a salary is fair market value for the work performed.
These factors include your experience, your duties, the time you devote to the business, and what similar positions in your industry and geographic area are paid. You must document how you arrived at your salary figure, as the burden of proof is on you during an audit.
| Payment Type | Tax Consequence for S-Corp Owner |
| Reasonable Salary | Subject to income tax and 15.3% FICA payroll tax. Reported on Form W-2. The corporation gets to deduct this as a business expense. |
| Distribution | Not subject to FICA payroll tax. Tax-free to the owner as long as it doesn’t exceed their shareholder basis. Reported on Schedule K-1. |
| Unreasonably Low Salary | The IRS reclassifies distributions as wages. The owner and corporation are hit with back payroll taxes, penalties, and interest on the reclassified amount. |
Export to Sheets
The Critical Role of Shareholder Basis
An S-Corp distribution is only tax-free to the extent of your shareholder basis. Think of basis as your total financial investment in the company. It is your personal responsibility to track it, not the corporation’s.
Your basis starts with your initial investment (cash or property). It then increases each year by your share of the company’s profits and any additional money you put in. It decreases by your share of any losses and by any distributions you take.
If you take a distribution that is larger than your basis, the excess amount is not tax-free. It is taxed as a capital gain. This is a classic trap for owners who take large distributions in a year when the company had a small profit or a loss, wiping out their basis and triggering an unexpected tax bill.
The C-Corporation and the Inevitability of Double Taxation
Life for a C-Corporation shareholder is much simpler, but often more costly from a tax perspective. A C-Corp is a completely separate taxpayer that files its own Form 1120 and pays a flat 21% federal corporate income tax on its profits.
Only after the corporation pays its taxes can it distribute the remaining profits to shareholders as dividends. When it does, the shareholder must report that dividend as income on their personal tax return and pay tax on it again. This is double taxation in its purest form.
To track this second layer of tax, the corporation must issue a Form 1099-DIV to any shareholder who receives $10 or more in dividends.
| Corporate Action | Tax Outcome |
| Corporation Earns Profit | The C-Corporation pays a 21% federal income tax on its net profit. This is the first layer of tax. |
| Corporation Pays Dividend | The shareholder receives the dividend and pays personal income tax on it (at qualified dividend rates of 0%, 15%, or 20%). This is the second layer of tax. |
| Corporation Reinvests Profit | If the corporation keeps the profits for business growth instead of paying a dividend, the second layer of tax is deferred. However, hoarding cash without a business reason can trigger an “accumulated earnings tax.” |
A Real-World C-Corp Example
Imagine a C-Corp earns $100,000 in profit. It first pays $21,000 in corporate income tax (21% rate), leaving $79,000. If it distributes that $79,000 to its owner, Mark, he will receive a Form 1099-DIV. Assuming Mark is in the 15% qualified dividend tax bracket, he will then pay an additional $11,850 in personal taxes. The original $100,000 of profit resulted in a total tax bill of $32,850.
The Three Most Common Shareholder Payout Scenarios
Understanding the rules is one thing; seeing them in action clarifies everything. Here are the three scenarios business owners encounter most frequently.
Scenario 1: The S-Corp Owner Balancing Salary and Distributions
Sarah is the sole owner and employee of her S-Corp. The business has a net profit of $150,000 before her salary. After researching her industry, she determines a reasonable salary for her role is $70,000.
| Action | Consequence |
| Sarah pays herself a $70,000 salary. | This amount is reported on her W-2. She and the corporation pay a combined ~$10,710 in FICA taxes on it. The corporation deducts the $70,000 as a business expense. |
| The corporation has $80,000 of profit remaining. | This profit passes through to Sarah’s personal tax return via Schedule K-1 and is taxed at her ordinary income rates. |
| Sarah takes an $80,000 distribution. | This cash payout is not subject to FICA taxes, saving her ~$12,240. As long as she has at least $80,000 of basis, the distribution is tax-free. |
Export to Sheets
Scenario 2: The C-Corp Owner Deciding on Dividends
Tom’s C-Corp has $200,000 in after-tax profits (retained earnings). He is the sole shareholder and needs to decide whether to take a dividend or reinvest the money.
| Decision | Tax Outcome |
| Tom has the C-Corp pay him a $100,000 dividend. | The corporation issues him a Form 1099-DIV. Tom reports the $100,000 on his personal return and pays tax on it (likely at the 15% or 20% qualified dividend rate). This is double taxation in action. |
| Tom decides to reinvest the $200,000 into the business. | No dividend is paid, so no Form 1099-DIV is issued. The second layer of tax is avoided for now. Tom must document a clear business purpose for retaining the earnings to avoid the accumulated earnings tax. |
Export to Sheets
Scenario 3: The S-Corp Distribution That Becomes Taxable
David is a 50% owner of an S-Corp. He starts the year with a stock basis of $10,000. The company breaks even for the year (zero profit), but it has cash reserves, so it makes a $40,000 distribution to him.
| Distribution Amount | Shareholder Tax Impact |
| The first $10,000 of the distribution. | This is a tax-free return of capital. It is not taxed, but it reduces David’s stock basis from $10,000 down to $0. |
| The remaining $30,000 of the distribution. | Because David’s basis is now zero, this portion of the distribution is a taxable capital gain. He must report a $30,000 capital gain on his personal tax return. |
Export to Sheets
Mistakes to Avoid: The Most Common and Costly Errors
Navigating these rules can be tricky, and a few common mistakes can lead to disastrous financial consequences.
- Paying an Unreasonably Low Salary. This is the number one red flag for S-Corp owners. The IRS is actively looking for owners paying themselves a tiny salary while taking large distributions. This can lead to a forced reclassification of distributions to wages, triggering a massive bill for back payroll taxes, penalties, and interest.
- Making Disproportionate Distributions. A core rule of S-Corps is the “one class of stock” requirement, which means all distributions must be paid proportional to ownership. If you and a partner are 50/50 owners, you must take equal distributions. Paying one owner more than another can, in a worst-case scenario, terminate your S-Corp status, converting you into a C-Corp and creating a tax nightmare.
- Losing Track of Shareholder Basis. It is the S-Corp shareholder’s job to track their basis, and many fail to do so. Without an accurate basis calculation, you cannot know if your distribution is a tax-free return of capital or a taxable capital gain. This mistake often surfaces during an audit or when the business is sold, leading to surprise tax bills.
- Improperly Documenting Shareholder Loans. If a shareholder takes a “loan” from the corporation without a formal promissory note, a market interest rate, and a repayment schedule, the IRS can reclassify it as a taxable distribution (or salary). This can trigger income tax and, in an S-Corp, could create a disproportionate distribution.
- Distributing Property with a “Built-In” Loss. If an S-Corp distributes property (like equipment or real estate) that is worth less than its tax basis, the corporation is not allowed to recognize the loss. The shareholder’s basis is still reduced by the property’s value, effectively making the loss vanish without any tax benefit for anyone.
S-Corp vs. C-Corp: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Choosing the right entity structure has profound and lasting tax consequences. The decision hinges on how you plan to take money out of the business and your long-term goals for growth and ownership.
| Feature | S-Corporation | C-Corporation |
| Taxation of Profits | Pass-Through. Profits are taxed once on the owners’ personal returns. | Double Taxation. Profits are taxed at the corporate level, then again when distributed as dividends. |
| Reporting Form for Payouts | Schedule K-1 for distributions. | Form 1099-DIV for dividends. |
| Payroll Taxes on Payouts | No payroll taxes on distributions. | No payroll taxes on dividends. |
| Ownership Restrictions | Limited to 100 shareholders, who must be U.S. citizens or residents. | No restrictions. Can have unlimited shareholders, including foreign investors and other corporations. |
| Stock Classes | Only one class of stock is allowed. | Multiple classes of stock (e.g., common, preferred) are allowed. |
Do’s and Don’ts for S-Corporation Owners
Operating an S-Corp successfully requires discipline. Follow these rules to stay compliant and maximize your tax benefits.
| Do’s | Don’ts |
| ✅ DO conduct and document a reasonable compensation analysis every year. This is your best defense in an IRS audit. | ❌ DON’T treat the business bank account like a personal ATM. Unplanned, sporadic withdrawals look like disguised salary to the IRS. |
| ✅ DO ensure all distributions are strictly proportional to ownership percentages. If you are a 60% owner, you get 60% of the total distributions. | ❌ DON’T take a large distribution in a year with a business loss without first checking your shareholder basis. You could accidentally create a taxable capital gain. |
| ✅ DO track your stock basis meticulously every single year. It is your personal responsibility and crucial for tax planning. | ❌ DON’T forget to pay quarterly estimated taxes. Since no tax is withheld from distributions, you must pay your taxes throughout the year. |
| ✅ DO use a formal, written promissory note for any loans between you and the corporation. This proves to the IRS that it is a legitimate loan, not a disguised distribution. | ❌ DON’T rely on informal “rules of thumb” like the 60/40 split for salary and distributions. The only standard that matters is the IRS’s “facts and circumstances” test. |
| ✅ DO hold regular, documented shareholder meetings to authorize distributions. This reinforces corporate formalities and protects your liability shield. | ❌ DON’T pay personal expenses directly from the business account. This creates bookkeeping headaches and can be viewed as a disproportionate distribution if not handled correctly. |
Pros and Cons of S-Corp vs. C-Corp Status
| Entity | Pros | Cons |
| S-Corporation | Tax Savings: Avoids double taxation on profits and allows for payroll tax savings on distributions. Pass-Through Losses: Business losses can be used to offset other personal income on your tax return (subject to basis limitations). | Strict Ownership Rules: Limited to 100 U.S. shareholders and only one class of stock, which can hinder raising capital. Rigid Profit Distribution: All distributions must be strictly proportional to ownership, offering no flexibility. |
| C-Corporation | Flexible Ownership: Can have unlimited shareholders of any type (including foreign investors) and multiple classes of stock, making it ideal for raising venture capital. Benefit Deductions: Can offer a wider range of tax-deductible fringe benefits to owners. | Double Taxation: Profits are taxed at both the corporate and shareholder levels, resulting in a higher overall tax rate on distributed earnings. Trapped Losses: Business losses cannot be passed through to owners to offset other income; they remain at the corporate level. |
Export to Sheets
Decoding the Forms: A Line-by-Line Guide
The information on these forms directly impacts your personal tax return. Knowing what the key boxes mean is essential.
Form 1099-DIV: For C-Corp Dividends
When your C-Corp pays you a dividend, you will receive a Form 1099-DIV.
- Box 1a – Total Ordinary Dividends: This is the total amount of dividends you received. This portion is generally taxed at your higher, ordinary income tax rates.
- Box 1b – Qualified Dividends: This is the amount from Box 1a that qualifies for lower tax rates. Qualified dividends are taxed at the more favorable long-term capital gains rates (0%, 15%, or 20%). The amount in Box 1b is already included in Box 1a; it is not an additional amount.
- Box 2a – Total Capital Gain Distributions: This is typically for distributions from mutual funds or Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs), not standard C-Corps. It is taxed at long-term capital gains rates.
- Box 3 – Nondividend Distributions: This is a return of capital. This amount is not taxable. Instead, it reduces your stock basis. If your basis is already zero, this amount is taxed as a capital gain.
Schedule K-1 (Form 1120-S): For S-Corp Distributions
Your S-Corp will issue you a Schedule K-1 each year. This form reports your share of the company’s income, deductions, and credits, which you must report on your personal return.
- Part I & II – Information about the Corporation & Shareholder: These sections identify the company and you, including your ownership percentage for the year.
- Part III – Shareholder’s Share of Current Year Income, Deductions, Credits, and Other Items: This is the core of the K-1. It lists your portion of the business’s financial activity (e.g., ordinary business income in Box 1, rental income in Box 2). You are taxed on these amounts whether you receive a cash distribution or not.
- Box 16 – Items Affecting Shareholder Basis: This box reports items that change your basis. The most important code here for payouts is:
- Code D – Distributions: This shows the total cash and property distributed to you during the year. This amount is generally tax-free and reduces your stock basis. It is not the same as the income reported elsewhere on the K-1.
Key Court Rulings That Shape the Rules
The IRS’s positions are not just internal guidelines; they are consistently tested and upheld in U.S. Tax Court.
- David E. Watson, P.C. v. U.S. (2012): This is the landmark case for reasonable compensation. Mr. Watson, an accountant, paid himself a $24,000 salary while taking over $175,000 in distributions. The court sided with the IRS, which argued a reasonable salary was over $90,000. The ruling confirmed that the IRS can and will reclassify distributions as wages if a salary is unreasonably low, regardless of the owner’s intent.
- Maggard v. Commissioner (2024): This recent case provided crucial clarification on disproportionate distributions. The court ruled that an unauthorized disproportionate distribution (in this case, embezzlement by majority owners) does not automatically create a second class of stock and terminate the S-election, as long as the corporation’s official governing documents (bylaws, articles of incorporation) confer identical rights to all shareholders. This provides a path to correct inadvertent errors without losing S-Corp status.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Q: Does my S-Corp distribution show up on a 1099? A: No. Profit distributions are reported on Schedule K-1, Box 16, Code D. You would only get a 1099-DIV from an S-Corp if it was previously a C-Corp and is distributing old C-Corp earnings.
2. Q: Do I pay Social Security and Medicare tax on my S-Corp distribution? A: No. S-Corp distributions are not subject to FICA (payroll) taxes. This is a primary tax advantage of the S-Corp structure, but it requires you to first pay yourself a reasonable salary, which is subject to FICA.
3. Q: Can I take a distribution if my S-Corp lost money this year? A: Yes, but be very careful. A distribution in a loss year will reduce your stock basis. This makes it highly likely the distribution will exceed your basis, triggering a taxable capital gain on the excess amount.
4. Q: My business partner and I are 50/50 S-Corp owners, but I do more work. Can I take a bigger distribution? A: No, absolutely not. Distributions must be proportional to ownership. You should compensate yourself for the extra work with a higher salary, not a larger distribution, to avoid violating the one-class-of-stock rule.
5. Q: Why is my “Shareholder Distribution” account negative in my accounting software? A: This is normal. Distributions are a reduction of your equity in the business, so they are recorded as a negative balance in the equity section of your balance sheet. It will be closed to retained earnings at year-end.
6. Q: What happens if I receive an incorrect Form 1099-DIV or Schedule K-1? A: Do not change the form yourself. Contact the company that issued it and request a corrected version. If they refuse, you can file Form 8082, Notice of Inconsistent Treatment, with your tax return to explain the discrepancy.
7. Q: Does a C-Corp get a tax deduction for paying dividends? A: No. This is a key feature of double taxation. The corporation pays tax on its profits and gets no deduction for distributing those after-tax profits to shareholders as dividends.
8. Q: Are all C-Corp dividends taxed at the same rate? A: No. “Qualified” dividends are taxed at lower long-term capital gains rates (0%, 15%, or 20%). “Nonqualified” or “ordinary” dividends are taxed at your regular, higher income tax rates. Your 1099-DIV will specify the amounts.