How to Fill Out New York Form TP-584.1 (w/Examples) + FAQs

New York Form TP-584.1 is the Real Estate Transfer Tax Return Supplemental Schedules that you attach to the main Form TP-584 when a real property transfer involves a cooperative housing corporation, a credit line mortgage, multiple parcels with apportioned consideration, or a transfer claimed to be without consideration. You file it with the county clerk (or the NYC Department of Finance ACRIS system for transfers in the five boroughs) at the same time you record the deed or transfer document.

If you skip a required schedule, the recording officer may reject your filing, and the New York Department of Taxation and Finance can later impose interest, penalties, and personal liability on both grantor and grantee under Tax Law §1404. The stakes are real because more than 250,000 deeds are recorded across New York every year, and roughly one in five of those transfers needs a TP-584.1 supplement, according to ACRIS recording data.

Here is what you will learn in this guide:

  • 📋 How to identify which TP-584.1 schedule (A, B, C, or D) applies to your transfer
  • 🏢 How co-op stock transfers, credit line mortgages, and multi-parcel deals each get their own math
  • 🧮 How to compute the base transfer tax, the additional base tax, and the mansion tax for 2026 closings
  • ⚠️ The seven most common mistakes filers make and the dollar consequences of each
  • ❓ Clear answers to the ten questions real estate attorneys, sellers, and buyers ask most often

What Is Form TP-584.1 and When Do You Need It

Form TP-584.1 is a four-schedule supplement to the main real estate transfer tax return. You only attach the schedule(s) that match your transaction. The form lives at the NY Tax Department forms page and is updated periodically, so always download the most current version before filing. The companion TP-584.1-I instructions walk through line items but assume the reader already knows the underlying Tax Law Article 31 framework.

The form exists because the basic TP-584 cannot capture every type of conveyance. A co-op transfer, for example, conveys shares of stock and a proprietary lease rather than real property in the traditional sense, so the state needs a different worksheet. A credit line mortgage assumed by a buyer must be valued under a special rule. A bulk sale of multiple parcels needs an allocation. A “gift” deed needs a sworn statement that no consideration changed hands.

You file TP-584.1 whenever any one of these four triggers fires:

  • The transfer is to or from a cooperative housing corporation, including original sponsor sales and resales of co-op shares
  • The instrument secures or releases a credit line mortgage as defined in Tax Law §253-b
  • A single deed conveys multiple tax parcels and the parties want to apportion the consideration among them
  • The grantor claims the transfer is for no consideration (gifts, beneficial-interest transfers, divorce decrees, deed corrections)

The consequence of guessing wrong is steep. If you mark “no consideration” but the IRS or NY auditor later finds hidden value, you owe the unpaid tax plus interest at the underpayment rate and a penalty of up to 25 percent under Tax Law §1416. A common misconception is that a sale between related parties for a nominal $10 is automatically a gift; it is not, because the state looks at fair market value when the parties are not at arm’s length.

Where TP-584.1 Fits in the Larger Filing Stack

When you record a deed in New York, you typically submit a packet that contains the deed itself, the RP-5217 equalization form, the TP-584, and any required TP-584.1 schedules. In New York City you also file the NYC-RPT for the city’s separate Real Property Transfer Tax. The county clerk or city register acts as the state’s collection agent, which means they will refuse to record your deed if the transfer-tax math on TP-584.1 does not reconcile with the consideration shown on the deed.

A practical example helps. Maria Alvarez sells her Queens co-op apartment to David Chen for $750,000. The deed (technically a stock-and-lease assignment) goes to ACRIS along with TP-584, Schedule A of TP-584.1, the RP-5217-NYC, and the NYC-RPT. If Maria’s attorney forgets Schedule A, ACRIS bounces the package, the closing is in limbo, and Maria’s mortgage payoff wire may sit overnight, costing her per-diem interest.

Schedule A — Conveyance of Cooperative Housing Corporation Stock

Schedule A handles co-op transfers, which represent roughly 800,000 units statewide and the bulk of Manhattan residential closings, according to the Real Estate Board of New York. Co-op transfers are taxed because Tax Law §1401(e) treats the conveyance of shares allocated to a residential dwelling unit in a cooperative housing corporation as a conveyance of real property. The plain-English rule is that the state looks through the corporate form to the underlying apartment.

The consequence of treating a co-op like personal property and skipping Schedule A is double trouble. First, the recording (or filing of the stock transfer) is incomplete. Second, the unpaid base transfer tax of $2 per $500 of consideration accrues interest from the closing date, not the audit date. A real-world scenario involves Jonathan Park, who sold his Upper West Side co-op for $1.4 million and tried to file only the TP-584 with the consideration listed; the NYC Department of Finance flagged the filing and assessed a late-filing penalty before the deed packet was finally accepted.

A common misconception is that original-issue co-op shares from a sponsor are exempt because they are “new” stock. They are not exempt; sponsor sales of newly issued shares are explicitly taxable under TSB-M-03(2)R, and the sponsor must file Schedule A line by line.

Line-by-Line Walkthrough of Schedule A

Line 1 asks for the name of the cooperative housing corporation, which must match the entity name on the stock certificate. A typo here will cause the city register to kick the form back. Line 2 asks for the address of the building and the unit number; this is the physical apartment, not the seller’s mailing address. Line 3 asks for the number of shares being transferred, which you pull from the stock power. Line 4 asks for total shares outstanding in the corporation, which you confirm with the managing agent. Line 5 computes the percentage of shares.

Line 6 reports the total consideration, defined under Tax Law §1401(d) to include cash, the value of any assumed mortgage on the underlying mortgage allocable to the unit, and any other property of value transferred to the seller. Line 7 lets you back out the share of any underlying blanket mortgage allocable to the unit, which is unique to co-ops and frequently missed by out-of-state filers. Line 8 is the net taxable consideration, and Line 9 multiplies that figure by the $2-per-$500 base rate to produce the tax.

The consequence of inflating Line 7 to lower the tax is a fraud exposure under Tax Law §1817, which is a misdemeanor for amounts under $10,000 and a felony above that threshold.

Schedule B — Credit Line Mortgage

Schedule B applies whenever the transfer involves a credit line mortgage, which is a recorded mortgage that secures a revolving line of credit such as a HELOC. The plain-English rule is that the state needs to know whether the line is being assumed, paid off, or assigned because each pathway changes the consideration number on TP-584.

The consequence of mishandling Schedule B is that the buyer may inadvertently take title subject to a live HELOC, exposing them to draws made by the seller after closing. A real-world scenario involves Priya Shah, who bought a Westchester home and accepted an assignment of the seller’s $200,000 credit line; her attorney failed to file Schedule B and did not freeze the line, and the seller drew $40,000 a week after closing, making Priya the unintended borrower.

A common misconception is that paying off the HELOC at closing eliminates the Schedule B requirement. It does not, because the satisfaction of a credit line mortgage at or before recording still requires the schedule to document the payoff and discharge under Tax Law §253-b.

Line-by-Line Walkthrough of Schedule B

Part 1 asks whether the credit line mortgage is being assigned, assumed, paid off, or kept open. You check exactly one box. Part 2 asks for the original principal amount of the credit line, which you take from the recorded mortgage. Part 3 asks for the outstanding principal at closing, which you confirm with a payoff letter from the lender. Part 4 calculates the additional mortgage recording tax, if any, on increases to the credit line.

The dollar stakes can be large. New York’s mortgage recording tax ranges from 1.05 percent to 2.80 percent depending on county and loan size, so a $500,000 credit line increase can trigger more than $14,000 of recording tax. Filers in Westchester and Erie counties are audited frequently because these counties cross-check Schedule B against the lender’s CEMA submission.

Schedule C — Apportionment of Consideration

Schedule C handles deals where one deed conveys two or more tax parcels and the parties want to allocate the purchase price among them. The plain-English rule is that you cannot lump the consideration together if the parcels have different uses (residential vs. commercial), different counties, or different transfer-tax exemptions. Apportionment matters because the mansion tax only applies to residential parcels priced at $1 million or more.

The consequence of skipping Schedule C is that the entire purchase price may be treated as residential, dragging a $400,000 commercial outparcel into the mansion tax base. A real-world scenario involves Kwame Johnson, an investor who bought a $2.4 million Long Island package consisting of a single-family home and an adjacent vacant lot; without Schedule C, the Suffolk County Clerk would have applied mansion tax to the entire $2.4 million instead of just the $1.6 million home, costing him an extra $8,000.

A common misconception is that the parties can pick any allocation they want. They cannot, because TSB-M-03(1)R requires the allocation to reflect fair market value supportable by an appraisal, broker price opinion, or assessed-value ratio.

How the Allocation Math Works

You list each parcel by section-block-lot, the use code, the allocated consideration, and the basis for that allocation. The total of the allocated amounts must equal the gross consideration on TP-584 line 1. If you are allocating to support a partial exemption (for example, a §1405(b)(8) conveyance to the federal government), you attach the appraisal or the sworn statement of the appraiser.

The consequence of an unsupported allocation is reallocation by the auditor at the highest mansion-tax-applicable ratio, plus interest. A practical tip is to request the assessor’s property record cards before closing so the allocation rests on official assessed values.

Schedule D — Conveyance for No Consideration or Beneficial-Interest Transfers

Schedule D is the schedule most often filed and most often filed incorrectly. It applies when the grantor swears that no consideration changed hands or that the transfer is merely a change in the form of ownership (for example, an individual deeding property into her own LLC). The legal anchor is Tax Law §1405 and its implementing 20 NYCRR §575.11.

The plain-English rule is that no money, no debt relief, and no other thing of value may pass between the parties, or the transfer is taxable. The consequence of getting this wrong is back tax, interest, and a penalty equal to 10 percent of the unpaid tax under Tax Law §1416(a)(1), and the grantor and grantee are jointly and severally liable.

Common Schedule D Triggers

Five fact patterns drive most Schedule D filings:

  • True gifts between family members with no debt assumption
  • Transfers from an individual to a wholly owned single-member LLC or revocable trust
  • Deed corrections or re-recordings to fix a scrivener’s error
  • Transfers pursuant to a divorce decree under Domestic Relations Law §236
  • Transfers among partners in a partnership where beneficial ownership does not change

A real-world scenario involves Elena Rodriguez, who deeded her Bronx three-family to her newly formed Rodriguez Holdings LLC. Because Elena owns 100 percent of the LLC and the property had no mortgage, Schedule D applied and the transfer tax was zero. Had the property carried a $500,000 mortgage, the debt-relief portion would have been treated as consideration and Schedule D would not have zeroed out the tax.

A common misconception is that adding a spouse to title is always tax-free. It is not, because if the spouse assumes part of an existing mortgage, the assumed share becomes consideration under 20 NYCRR §575.1.

The Sworn Statement and Beneficial-Ownership Disclosure

Schedule D requires a sworn statement signed by both grantor and grantee certifying the facts that support no consideration. After 2019, Tax Law §1409(a) requires LLC grantors and grantees of one-to-four-family residences to disclose every member, manager, and authorized person, drilling all the way up to natural persons. The consequence of omitting a single member is rejection of the recording under the LLC transparency rule, and the property cannot be conveyed until the disclosure is amended.

This disclosure overlaps with — but is not the same as — the federal FinCEN Beneficial Ownership Information report. New York’s rule is recording-driven; FinCEN’s rule is entity-driven. Filers must comply with both.

2026 Transfer Tax Rates You Plug Into TP-584.1

The numbers on Schedules A through D ultimately feed into the tax calculation on the main TP-584. The base transfer tax remains $2 per $500 of consideration (or 0.4 percent) statewide under Tax Law §1402. The additional base tax of 0.25 percent applies to residential conveyances of $3 million or more and to commercial conveyances of $2 million or more, under Tax Law §1402-b.

The mansion tax kicks in at $1 million for residential conveyances under Tax Law §1402-a and rises through progressive brackets up to 3.9 percent at $25 million and above, as confirmed in the NY Tax Department mansion tax bulletin. New York City layers its own RPTT on top, ranging from 1.0 to 2.625 percent depending on consideration and use.

Worked Example Tying It All Together

Aisha Brown sells her Manhattan condo for $4.2 million to Liam O’Connor in June 2026. The state base tax is $4,200,000 × 0.004 = $16,800. The state additional base tax (residential, $3M+) is $4,200,000 × 0.0025 = $10,500. The state mansion tax at the $4M-to-$5M tier is 2.25 percent, or $94,500. The NYC RPTT at 1.425 percent is $59,850. Because the deal is a straight cash sale of a single condo unit, Aisha and Liam need TP-584, RP-5217-NYC, and NYC-RPT, but no TP-584.1 schedule applies. If Aisha had taken back a purchase-money credit line mortgage, Schedule B would attach.

Three Most Popular TP-584.1 Scenarios

Below are three fact patterns advisors see week in and week out. Each table has exactly two columns to keep the cause-and-effect tight.

Scenario 1 — Co-op Resale With Underlying Mortgage

Filer Step Tax Outcome
Seller files Schedule A, lists 350 of 50,000 shares Triggers $2/$500 base rate on net consideration
Seller deducts allocable share of building’s underlying mortgage on Line 7 Reduces taxable consideration and the base tax
Buyer pays NYC RPTT at 1.425% (consideration $1M+) City tax stacks on top of state tax
Both parties sign Schedule A and TP-584 Avoids §1404 joint-and-several liability gap

Scenario 2 — Deed Into Single-Member LLC

Filer Step Tax Outcome
Grantor files Schedule D, claims no consideration Zero base transfer tax if no debt assumption
Grantor discloses all LLC members up to natural persons Satisfies §1409(a) LLC transparency rule
Mortgage stays in original borrower’s name Avoids §1402 debt-relief consideration
File CEMA if refinance follows Avoids duplicate mortgage recording tax

Scenario 3 — Multi-Parcel Mixed-Use Sale

Filer Step Tax Outcome
Allocate consideration on Schedule C using assessed-value ratio Supports allocation under TSB-M-03(1)R
Apply mansion tax only to residential parcel above $1M Saves up to 3.9% on commercial portion
Apply additional base tax to commercial parcel above $2M Captures correct §1402-b liability
Attach appraisal or assessor cards Defends allocation on audit

Three Named Examples to Anchor the Rules

Maria Alvarez in Queens uses Schedule A to sell her co-op for $750,000 and saves $480 by correctly deducting the unit’s pro-rata share of the building’s $5 million underlying mortgage on Line 7. Her closing attorney pulls the allocation from the managing agent’s letter the week before closing.

Priya Shah in Westchester uses Schedule B to document the assumption of a $200,000 credit line mortgage. Her attorney also files a written request to freeze the line under the lender’s standard procedure, which is the practical step that stops post-closing draws but is not part of the form itself.

Elena Rodriguez in the Bronx uses Schedule D to deed her three-family into Rodriguez Holdings LLC. She lists herself as the sole member on the LLC disclosure, attaches her biennial statement reference number, and pays zero state transfer tax because she retained 100 percent beneficial ownership and the building was unencumbered.

Mistakes to Avoid

Filers repeatedly stumble on the same issues, each with measurable dollar consequences:

  • Treating a co-op like personal property and skipping Schedule A — the consequence is a rejected ACRIS package and a per-diem interest hit on the seller’s mortgage payoff
  • Forgetting the underlying mortgage deduction on Schedule A Line 7 — the consequence is overpayment of $400 to $1,500 of base tax that is hard to recover via refund claim under §1412
  • Marking “paid off” on Schedule B without attaching the lender’s satisfaction of mortgage — the consequence is a clouded title and refusal of title insurance
  • Allocating Schedule C purchase prices without a supporting valuation — the consequence is reallocation by the auditor at the worst-case ratio
  • Filing Schedule D for a transfer where the grantee assumes a mortgage — the consequence is back tax on the full debt-relief amount plus 10 percent penalty
  • Omitting an LLC member from the §1409(a) disclosure — the consequence is rejection of recording and inability to convey
  • Using stale form revisions downloaded years ago — the consequence is rejection because the forms page updates the OCR codes annually
  • Filing TP-584.1 without the corresponding TP-584 — the consequence is a void filing because TP-584.1 is a supplement, not a stand-alone return
  • Mis-checking the “exempt” box on TP-584 when the only exemption is partial — the consequence is loss of the partial exemption and full tax assessment

Do’s and Don’ts

A short list helps both first-time filers and seasoned attorneys keep the right reflexes.

  • Do download the current TP-584.1 from the official forms page the day of closing because the form is updated periodically
  • Do confirm the underlying mortgage allocation on co-ops with the managing agent in writing because verbal estimates do not survive audit
  • Do attach a fair-market-value support document to every Schedule C allocation because TSB-M-03(1)R demands it
  • Do collect every LLC member’s name and address before closing because the §1409(a) disclosure blocks recording without it
  • Do reconcile the consideration on the deed, the TP-584, and the TP-584.1 because a $1 mismatch will trigger rejection
  • Don’t accept a “gift” characterization without verifying that no debt is being assumed because debt relief is consideration under 20 NYCRR §575.1
  • Don’t assume sponsor co-op sales are exempt because TSB-M-03(2)R confirms they are taxable
  • Don’t allocate Schedule C arbitrarily because auditors reallocate at the highest applicable rate
  • Don’t ignore the NYC RPTT layer because it stacks on top of the state tax and has its own NYC-RPT form
  • Don’t sign a sworn statement on Schedule D unless the facts truly support no consideration because perjury exposure exists under Tax Law §1817

Pros and Cons of Filing TP-584.1 Yourself

Some grantors and grantees attempt to file TP-584.1 without an attorney, especially for simple gift deeds. Weighing the trade-offs honestly avoids surprises.

  • Pro: You save legal fees, which range from $750 to $2,500 for a routine deed transfer in New York
  • Pro: You learn the moving parts of Article 31, which helps with future estate planning
  • Pro: You control timing and can record the same day rather than wait on a busy attorney
  • Pro: For a true §1405 exempt transfer, the form is short and the math is zero
  • Pro: You build a paper trail you understand because you assembled it
  • Con: A single error voids the recording and your closing date slips
  • Con: You may miss the LLC disclosure rule and stall the deed indefinitely
  • Con: You take on personal liability under §1404 for any tax shortfall
  • Con: You cannot get title insurance without a clean tax filing, which means you cannot resell or refinance
  • Con: You lose attorney-client privilege over your tax positions, which matters if NY audits you later

Key Entities You Should Know

The TP-584.1 ecosystem includes several actors whose roles shape the outcome of your filing.

The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance writes the form, sets the rates, and audits returns. The New York State Senate houses Article 31 of the Tax Law, which is the statutory authority. County clerks and the NYC Department of Finance collect the tax at recording. The New York Department of State houses LLC formation records used to verify §1409(a) disclosures.

REBNY publishes co-op transfer practice guides used by Manhattan attorneys. FinCEN collects parallel federal beneficial-ownership data. The American Land Title Association sets practice standards for the title insurance underwriters that depend on your TP-584.1 being correct. Cornell Law’s LII provides free public access to the underlying statutes and regulations.

Recap of Key Rulings and Guidance

Matter of GKK 2 Herald LLC v. Tax Appeals Tribunal confirmed that the transfer tax base includes the assumption of debt even when the parties label the transaction a contribution to capital. The TSB-M-03(1)R memorandum governs Schedule C allocations. The TSB-M-03(2)R memorandum confirms the taxability of sponsor co-op sales.

Matter of 1605 Book Center, Inc. v. Tax Appeals Tribunal clarified that consideration includes the assumption of contingent obligations when reasonably ascertainable. The 2019 LLC transparency amendments added the §1409(a) disclosure rule. Together, these authorities form the backbone of every TP-584.1 audit and should anchor any defense if the Tax Department challenges your filing.

Step-by-Step Filing Walkthrough

The mechanical steps look the same for most transactions, with branches at Schedule selection.

First, identify which schedule applies by walking the four triggers (co-op, credit line, multi-parcel, no consideration). Second, gather supporting documents — stock power, payoff letter, appraisal, or LLC operating agreement. Third, complete TP-584 first because the schedules feed into TP-584’s tax computation lines. Fourth, complete the applicable TP-584.1 schedule(s) and reconcile the numbers to TP-584 and to the deed. Fifth, sign and notarize where indicated; note that Schedule D requires both parties’ sworn signatures.

Sixth, file electronically through ACRIS for NYC properties or in person at the county clerk’s office outside the city. Seventh, pay all taxes by certified check or wire because personal checks bounce closings. Eighth, retain stamped copies for at least three years under Tax Law §1411, which is the audit window for transfer tax.

The consequence of skipping any step is delay at best and personal liability at worst. The State Comptroller’s audit reports regularly identify TP-584 and TP-584.1 errors as a top source of recovered transfer tax, with annual recoveries exceeding $30 million.

FAQs

Do I always need TP-584.1 with TP-584?

No. You only attach TP-584.1 when your transaction triggers Schedule A, B, C, or D. Straight cash sales of a single fee-simple parcel use TP-584 alone with no supplemental schedule.

Is a co-op transfer subject to the mansion tax?

Yes. Co-op transfers of residential units are subject to the 1 percent mansion tax and the higher progressive brackets when the consideration meets or exceeds $1 million.

Does deeding my home into my own LLC trigger transfer tax?

No. A transfer to a wholly owned LLC with no debt assumption qualifies as a mere change in form under Tax Law §1405 and is reported on Schedule D with zero tax due.

Is a transfer between divorcing spouses taxable?

No. Transfers pursuant to a divorce decree under DRL §236 are exempt and reported on Schedule D, provided no outside consideration is paid beyond the equitable distribution.

Do I need to disclose every LLC member?

Yes. For one-to-four-family homes, Tax Law §1409(a) requires disclosure of every member, manager, and authorized person, traced up to natural persons.

Can I correct a recorded TP-584.1 after filing?

Yes. You file an amended TP-584 and TP-584.1 with the NY Tax Department and request a refund or remit additional tax under Tax Law §1412, within three years of the original filing.

Is the sponsor’s first sale of co-op shares taxable?

Yes. The original issuance of co-op shares from a sponsor is taxable under TSB-M-03(2)R and requires Schedule A.

Does paying off a HELOC at closing eliminate Schedule B?

No. You must still file Schedule B to document the satisfaction of the credit line mortgage and confirm the lender’s discharge under Tax Law §253-b.

Are gift transfers between parent and child tax-free?

Yes. A true gift with no debt assumption is exempt under Tax Law §1405 and reported on Schedule D, but the IRS gift tax rules under IRC §2501 still apply at the federal level.

Who is liable if the tax is unpaid?

Yes, both parties are liable. Under Tax Law §1404, the grantor is primarily liable, but the grantee becomes liable if the grantor fails to pay, making both jointly responsible.

Does TP-584.1 apply to commercial property?

Yes. Commercial transfers use TP-584.1 whenever the deal involves a credit line mortgage or multi-parcel apportionment, even though the mansion tax does not apply to commercial parcels.

How long do I keep TP-584.1 records?

Yes, keep them at least three years. Tax Law §1411 sets a three-year audit window, but most practitioners recommend retaining records for seven years to align with IRS recordkeeping rules.