How to Fill Out New York Stipulation of Discontinuance (w/Examples) + FAQs

A New York Stipulation of Discontinuance is a written agreement, signed by every party who has appeared in a lawsuit, that voluntarily ends the case without a trial or judgment. You fill it out by listing the court, index number, caption, parties, the statute (CPLR 3217(a)(2)), the words “with prejudice” or “without prejudice,” signatures of all counsel or self-represented parties, and the date, then file it with the County Clerk through NYSCEF or in paper form.

The problem this form solves is huge. Lawsuits cost money, time, and stress. According to the New York State Unified Court System 2024 Annual Report, more than 3.1 million cases were filed across New York courts last year, and roughly 97% ended without a trial. Most of those endings are paperwork-driven, and the Stipulation of Discontinuance is the single most common tool used to close a civil case voluntarily.

Here is what you will learn in this guide:

  • 📜 The exact CPLR rules that govern voluntary discontinuance and when each one applies
  • ✍️ A line-by-line walkthrough of how to fill out the stipulation, with named-person examples
  • ⚖️ The real legal consequences of choosing with prejudice versus without prejudice
  • 🏛️ How to file in every New York court, including NYSCEF e-filing and paper filing
  • 🚫 The seven most damaging mistakes litigants make and how to avoid each one

What a Stipulation of Discontinuance Means in New York

A Stipulation of Discontinuance is a contract between the parties to a lawsuit that tells the court the case is over. It is authorized by CPLR 3217, which is the statute that governs voluntary dismissals in every New York civil court. The stipulation does not need a judge’s signature when every party who has appeared signs it, which is what makes it so popular.

The plain-English meaning is simple. The plaintiff agrees to drop the case, the defendant agrees to accept that drop, and both sides walk away on terms they have negotiated privately. The consequence of filing one is that the court loses authority to decide the merits of the dispute, except to enforce the stipulation itself under the rule announced in Teitelbaum Holdings v. Gold, 48 N.Y.2d 51 (1979).

A real-world example helps. Maria Gonzalez sues her former landlord in Bronx Civil Court for the return of a security deposit. After mediation, the landlord pays her in full. Maria signs a Stipulation of Discontinuance with prejudice, the landlord signs it, and the case ends without a judgment on either side’s record.

A common misconception is that a Stipulation of Discontinuance is the same as a settlement agreement. It is not. The settlement is the private deal about money or behavior, while the stipulation is the public court filing that closes the docket. You almost always need both documents to fully wrap up a case.

The Three Statutory Paths Under CPLR 3217

CPLR 3217 creates three different ways to discontinue a New York civil action. The first is a unilateral Notice of Discontinuance under subsection (a)(1), which the plaintiff alone files before the defendant serves a responsive pleading or within twenty days after service of the complaint, whichever is earlier. The second is the Stipulation of Discontinuance under subsection (a)(2), which requires the signatures of every party who has appeared. The third is a court-ordered discontinuance under subsection (b), which a judge grants on motion when the parties cannot agree.

The consequence of using the wrong path is dismissal of your filing. If you try to file a unilateral notice after the defendant has already answered, the clerk will reject it and you will keep accruing legal fees. The savvy choice in most settled cases is the (a)(2) stipulation because it locks in mutual release language.

A common misconception is that a defendant who never appeared still has to sign. They do not. Only parties who have appeared in the action — meaning filed an answer, a motion, or a notice of appearance — must sign the stipulation under CPLR 3217(a)(2).

Federal Versus New York State Rules

Federal courts use Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a), which is similar but not identical to New York’s rule. Under FRCP 41(a)(1)(A)(ii), a federal stipulation also requires the signatures of all parties who have appeared, and the dismissal is presumed without prejudice unless the document says otherwise.

The consequence of confusing the two systems is fatal. If your case is in the Southern District of New York, you must follow Rule 41 and the local civil rules, not the CPLR. Filing the wrong template can leave the case open and continue the statute-of-limitations clock for the defendant’s counterclaims.

For example, David Kim removes a state contract case to federal court. His lawyer reflexively files a CPLR 3217 stipulation. The federal clerk flags it, the case stays open for two more months, and David’s malpractice carrier later pays the resulting fees. The lesson is to always match the form to the forum.

When You Can and Cannot Use a Stipulation of Discontinuance

You can use a Stipulation of Discontinuance at almost any stage of a New York civil action, from the day after service of the complaint until the moment before the jury returns a verdict. The rule under CPLR 3217(a)(2) says the stipulation works “at any time” before submission of the case to the court or jury. That breadth is one of the biggest reasons litigants prefer it over a contested motion to dismiss.

You cannot use it, however, in certain protected case types. CPLR 3217(c) and the Domestic Relations Law place limits on matrimonial actions, class actions under CPLR 908, shareholder derivative suits, infant compromise proceedings, and wrongful death actions. In each of those, a judge must approve the discontinuance to protect absent parties.

The consequence of filing a stipulation in a protected case without judicial approval is that the dismissal is void. The court treats the case as still open, which means the statute of limitations on counterclaims keeps tolling and the parties remain exposed.

A common misconception is that any settled divorce can be ended by stipulation alone. It cannot. Under DRL § 211, a matrimonial action requires either a judgment of divorce or a court-approved discontinuance, and the Uniform Rules for Matrimonial Actions reinforce that. Skipping this step leaves the parties technically still married.

Class Actions and Derivative Suits

Under CPLR 908, a class action cannot be discontinued without notice to all class members and approval by the court. The reason is that absent class members are bound by the result, and they deserve a chance to object. The consequence of filing a private stipulation in a certified class case is reversal on appeal, as the First Department reaffirmed in Desrosiers v. Perry Ellis Menswear, 30 N.Y.3d 488 (2017).

For example, Jasmine Patel leads a wage-and-hour class action against a restaurant chain. She negotiates a private payout for herself and tries to discontinue. The trial court rejects the stipulation under CPLR 908, and Jasmine has to either send class notice or proceed with the case. The protective rule prevents named plaintiffs from selling out the class.

Infant Compromise and Wrongful Death

CPLR 1207 and CPLR 1208 require court approval for any settlement or discontinuance involving a minor or person with a disability. The same is true for wrongful death actions under EPTL 5-4.6, where the Surrogate’s Court or the trial court must approve the allocation of proceeds among distributees.

The consequence of skipping this approval is personal liability for the attorney and the guardian. Insurance carriers will refuse to release settlement funds without a signed compromise order. Always pair the stipulation with the appropriate infant-compromise order before filing.

Line-by-Line Instructions for Filling Out the Form

The official template is found in the New York Courts forms library and on most county clerk websites. The form has no single statewide PDF, so you will see slight variations between counties, but every version contains the same nine elements. Filling each one correctly is what makes the document enforceable.

The reason these elements matter is that the County Clerk uses them to update the docket and close the case in UCMS, the state’s case management system. A stipulation that is missing the index number or the caption will be returned, and the case will remain open until you re-file. That delay can cost you the protection of a settlement deadline.

The example to keep in mind is Anthony Russo, a small-business owner who settled a $40,000 commercial dispute. His paralegal forgot to include the index number on the stipulation. The County Clerk in Nassau County rejected the filing twice, and the defendant tried to back out of the settlement during the delay. Anthony only saved the deal by getting a same-day order from the judge.

A common misconception is that you can leave the date blank and let the clerk fill it in. Never do that. The date drives the discontinuance’s effective date and any release language tied to it.

Caption, Court, and Index Number

The top of the form must mirror the caption on the original summons and complaint exactly. That means the same plaintiff names, defendant names, court name, and county. The index number, assigned at filing under CPLR 306-a, is the unique identifier and must be typed in full, including the year prefix.

The consequence of a mismatched caption is rejection. The clerk uses optical scanning, and a misspelled name or wrong county sends the document to a manual review queue that can take weeks. For example, Linda Thompson sued “ABC Corp.” but typed “ABC Corporation” on the stipulation. The filing bounced, and her settlement check was held in escrow for three extra weeks.

A common misconception is that adding “et al.” is enough. It is not. List every named party, even if the action originally had ten defendants and only two remain.

Body Paragraph and Statutory Citation

The body of the stipulation typically reads, “IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED, by and between the undersigned, the attorneys of record for all parties to the above-entitled action, that whereas no party hereto is an infant or incompetent person for whom a committee has been appointed and no person not a party has an interest in the subject matter of the action, the above-entitled action be, and the same hereby is, discontinued with prejudice / without prejudice, without costs to either party as against the other.” That language tracks CPLR 3217(a)(2) and the model form recommended by the New York State Bar Association.

The reason for the “no infant or incompetent” recital is to confirm that no court approval is needed under CPLR 1207. Skipping the recital gives the clerk a reason to question the filing. Always include it even if the parties are clearly adults.

A common misconception is that “without costs” is optional language. It is not optional in practice. Without it, either party could later file a bill of costs under CPLR 8101 and tax the other side hundreds of dollars in disbursements.

With Prejudice Versus Without Prejudice

The single most important word choice on the form is “with prejudice” or “without prejudice.” A discontinuance with prejudice operates like a final judgment on the merits and bars any later lawsuit on the same claim under the doctrine of res judicata described in O’Brien v. City of Syracuse, 54 N.Y.2d 353 (1981). A discontinuance without prejudice simply ends this case and leaves the plaintiff free to refile, subject to the statute of limitations.

The consequence of choosing wrong is permanent. If a plaintiff signs “with prejudice” and later discovers new evidence, no amount of motion practice can revive the case. The trial court will dismiss any new complaint on res judicata grounds.

For example, Robert Chen settles a personal injury case for $25,000 and signs a stipulation with prejudice. Six months later, he learns that his injuries are far worse than diagnosed. He cannot reopen the case, and his only remedy is to argue fraud in the inducement, which is hard to prove.

A common misconception is that “without prejudice” tolls the statute of limitations. It does not. Under CPLR 205(a), a plaintiff who voluntarily discontinues does not get the six-month savings period that would otherwise apply to involuntary terminations.

Signatures, Notarization, and Date

Every party who has appeared must sign, either personally if pro se or through counsel of record. Under CPLR 2104, the stipulation must be in writing and subscribed, meaning hand-signed or e-signed in compliance with the New York Electronic Signatures and Records Act. Notarization is not required by the CPLR, although some County Clerks request it for paper filings.

The consequence of a missing signature is unenforceability. In Bonnette v. Long Is. Coll. Hosp., 3 N.Y.3d 281 (2004), the Court of Appeals held that an unsigned email cannot satisfy CPLR 2104 unless it contains the sender’s typed name as a signature. Make sure each party’s signature block has a printed name, firm name, address, phone number, and email.

A common misconception is that one defense lawyer can sign for multiple represented defendants without separate authority. They cannot. Each represented party needs explicit consent, and best practice is a separate signature line for each.

How to File the Stipulation of Discontinuance

Filing happens either electronically through NYSCEF or in paper form at the County Clerk’s office where the case was originally filed. The choice depends on whether the case is e-filed or paper. Once filed, the County Clerk marks the case “disposed” in UCMS.

The filing fee for a stipulation under CPLR 8020 is generally $35 for Supreme Court paper filings, and there is no separate fee for NYSCEF uploads in most counties. Fee waivers are available under CPLR 1101 for indigent parties. Always confirm the current schedule on the Office of Court Administration fee page.

For example, Aisha Williams settles a Queens Supreme Court case and uploads the stipulation to NYSCEF at 11:55 p.m. on the deadline. The system timestamps it the same calendar day, and her settlement closes on time. Without NYSCEF, she would have had to wait until the County Clerk opened the next morning.

NYSCEF E-Filing Steps

To file electronically, log into NYSCEF, open the case by index number, choose File Documents, select the document type “Stipulation of Discontinuance,” upload the PDF, certify the filing, and submit. The system emails confirmation to all counsel of record within minutes.

The consequence of skipping the certification page is rejection. NYSCEF requires the filer to confirm under 22 NYCRR 202.5-bb that the document complies with court rules and that all signatures are valid. The certification box is small but mandatory.

Paper Filing in the County Clerk’s Office

For paper cases, bring the original signed stipulation, two copies, and the filing fee to the County Clerk. The clerk stamps each copy and returns one for your file. Some counties, like New York County, also require a Request for Judicial Intervention be marked closed if one had been filed.

The consequence of forgetting the RJI update is that the case stays on the judge’s calendar, and you may receive a status conference notice months later. Always check the docket sheet a week after filing to confirm the case is closed.

Three Most Common Stipulation Scenarios

The three patterns below cover the vast majority of New York stipulations. Each appears as a 2-column table showing the Filing Choice and the Real-World Outcome. These are not the only patterns, but they are the ones most readers will face.

Personal Injury Settlement After Mediation

Filing Choice Real-World Outcome
Stipulation with prejudice plus general release Plaintiff cannot refile, defendant pays settlement, insurer closes file
Forgetting to add “without costs” language Defendant taxes $400 in disbursements after the fact
Using FRCP 41 form in state court Clerk rejects filing, settlement check held in escrow
Skipping infant compromise order for minor plaintiff Court voids stipulation, settlement funds frozen until approval

Credit Card Debt Case Settled for Less Than Demand

Filing Choice Real-World Outcome
Stipulation without prejudice plus written settlement Debtor pays agreed sum, creditor reserves right to refile if default
Stipulation with prejudice without payment plan Creditor loses right to sue if debtor breaches
Missing defendant signature on consent Clerk rejects, case stays open and accrues interest

Commercial Breach of Contract Withdrawal

Filing Choice Real-World Outcome
Mutual stipulation with prejudice and mutual release Both sides walk away, neither can sue on same facts
Plaintiff-only notice under CPLR 3217(a)(1) after answer Clerk rejects, plaintiff must seek court order
Failure to update NYSCEF case status Judge issues sua sponte status conference order

Three Named-Person Examples

Real names and goals make abstract rules concrete. The three vignettes below illustrate how the stipulation works in different practice areas.

Example 1: Sofia Martinez, Slip-and-Fall Plaintiff

Sofia Martinez slips on ice outside a Manhattan deli and sues for $75,000. The deli’s insurer offers $40,000 to settle, conditioned on a discontinuance with prejudice and a general release. Sofia’s attorney drafts the stipulation citing CPLR 3217(a)(2), inserts the with prejudice language, includes the “no infant” recital, and uploads it through NYSCEF the same day she receives the settlement check. The case closes within 48 hours, and Sofia has no further obligations.

The lesson is that pairing the stipulation with a separate release is the safest practice. The stipulation closes the court file, while the release closes the legal claim itself.

Example 2: Marcus Johnson, Pro Se Tenant

Marcus Johnson sues his landlord in Kings County Civil Court for return of a $2,800 security deposit. After the landlord pays, Marcus types up a one-page stipulation following the self-help template at LawHelpNY, signs it, gets the landlord’s signature, and walks it to the County Clerk. He pays no fee because CPLR 8020 exempts certain housing matters, and the clerk stamps it closed.

The lesson is that pro se litigants can use the form successfully if they follow the template and confirm that no fee applies in their case type.

Example 3: Priya Shah, Commercial Plaintiff

Priya Shah, owner of a small import business, sues a supplier in Queens Supreme Court Commercial Division for $250,000 in damaged goods. The parties mediate under the Commercial Division Mediation Program, reach a settlement, and exchange a stipulation with prejudice plus mutual releases. Priya’s lawyer files via NYSCEF, includes the certification page, and the case is closed within hours.

The lesson is that even high-value commercial cases use the same one-page stipulation. The complexity lives in the side agreements, not the court form.

Mistakes to Avoid

Every busy litigator has a war story about a stipulation that went wrong. The list below covers the seven most damaging mistakes and the consequence of each. Avoid them and you will save your client time, money, and embarrassment.

  • Using with prejudice when the client wants to refile later, which permanently bars the claim under O’Brien v. City of Syracuse.
  • Leaving out the “no infant or incompetent” recital, which gives the clerk grounds to reject the filing under CPLR 1207.
  • Failing to obtain every appearing party’s signature, which renders the stipulation unenforceable under CPLR 3217(a)(2).
  • Filing a CPLR stipulation in federal court, which violates FRCP 41 and leaves the case open.
  • Forgetting to discontinue counterclaims and cross-claims, which keeps those claims alive even after the main action is closed.
  • Skipping court approval in a class action, infant, or wrongful death case, which voids the dismissal under CPLR 908.
  • Treating an unsigned email exchange as a stipulation, which fails CPLR 2104 and leaves the deal unenforceable.

Do’s and Don’ts of New York Discontinuance Practice

The following lists distill the rules into quick decisions. Each item includes the why so you can apply the principle to new facts.

Do’s:

  • Do confirm every party who has appeared signs the stipulation, because CPLR 3217(a)(2) requires unanimous consent.
  • Do specify with or without prejudice in plain text, because the default rule under CPLR 3217(c) treats a second voluntary dismissal as on the merits.
  • Do file through NYSCEF when the case is e-filed, because paper filings in e-filed cases are rejected under 22 NYCRR 202.5-bb.
  • Do pair the stipulation with a separate release, because the stipulation closes the docket but a release extinguishes the underlying claim.
  • Do save the time-stamped confirmation, because it is your only proof the case was timely closed under any settlement deadline.

Don’ts:

  • Don’t use a notice of discontinuance after the defendant answers, because CPLR 3217(a)(1) bars it.
  • Don’t skip the “without costs” language, because CPLR 8101 lets a party tax disbursements absent that waiver.
  • Don’t forget to address counterclaims, because they survive an unaddressed plaintiff’s discontinuance.
  • Don’t rely on oral agreements, because CPLR 2104 demands a writing or open-court statement.
  • Don’t assume the County Clerk will fix errors, because rejected filings simply sit in the queue while the docket stays open.

Pros and Cons of Voluntary Discontinuance

Voluntary discontinuance is powerful but not always the right tool. The lists below balance the benefits against the costs.

Pros:

  • Speed, because a fully signed stipulation closes a case in minutes through NYSCEF.
  • Cost savings, because the filing fee under CPLR 8020 is far lower than continued litigation expenses.
  • Privacy, because the stipulation usually contains no factual recitals and the underlying settlement stays confidential.
  • Certainty, because a with prejudice discontinuance triggers res judicata under O’Brien v. City of Syracuse.
  • Flexibility, because the parties choose the timing, scope, and prejudice level themselves.

Cons:

  • Loss of refiling rights when with prejudice is selected, because the doctrine of claim preclusion bars new actions.
  • No CPLR 205(a) savings under CPLR 205, because voluntary dismissals are excluded from the six-month refiling window.
  • Risk of the two-dismissal rule under CPLR 3217(c), where a second voluntary dismissal counts as on the merits.
  • Required court approval in protected case types under CPLR 908, which adds time and cost.
  • Possible enforcement disputes if the stipulation lacks a release, because Teitelbaum limits the court’s residual power.

Form Walkthrough Recap and Court-by-Court Nuances

Every New York court accepts the same basic stipulation, but each has its own quirks. Supreme Court matters in New York County, Kings County, and Queens County require NYSCEF uploads in nearly all civil cases. New York City Civil Court uses a slightly different caption format, and Town and Village Courts often accept handwritten stipulations.

The reason the rules vary is administrative, not substantive. The CPLR governs everywhere, while the Uniform Rules for the Trial Courts handle filing logistics. Always check the local part rules of the assigned judge, which are posted on the court’s part rules page.

A common misconception is that Surrogate’s Court and Family Court use the same stipulation. They do not. Surrogate’s matters use a decree on consent, and Family Court matters typically use a withdrawal form under Family Court Act § 1051. Using the wrong form there will get your filing rejected.

Key Court Rulings That Shape the Form

Three rulings shape modern stipulation practice. Teitelbaum Holdings v. Gold, 48 N.Y.2d 51 (1979) holds that once a discontinuance is filed, the trial court’s only remaining power is to enforce the stipulation itself. Bonnette v. Long Is. Coll. Hosp., 3 N.Y.3d 281 (2004) confirms that emails can satisfy CPLR 2104 only if they contain a typed signature. Forcelli v. Gelco Corp., 109 A.D.3d 244 (2d Dep’t 2013) extends that rule to settlement communications generally.

The consequence of ignoring these rulings is loss of enforceability. A handshake deal or an unsigned email is not a stipulation, period. Always reduce the agreement to a properly signed writing.

A common misconception is that older cases like Teitelbaum are obsolete. They are not. The Court of Appeals continues to cite them, and the Appellate Division applies them in nearly every enforcement dispute.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a lawyer to file a Stipulation of Discontinuance in New York?

No. Self-represented litigants can fill out and file the form, although consulting with counsel before signing with prejudice is wise to avoid losing future claims under CPLR 3217.

Does a Stipulation of Discontinuance need to be notarized?

No. CPLR 2104 requires only a writing subscribed by the parties or their attorneys, although some County Clerks request notarization for paper filings.

Can I file a stipulation if the defendant has not appeared?

Yes. A plaintiff may file a unilateral notice of discontinuance under CPLR 3217(a)(1) before the defendant serves an answer or within twenty days of service.

Does with prejudice mean the case is over forever?

Yes. A discontinuance with prejudice operates like a final judgment on the merits and bars any later lawsuit on the same facts under the doctrine of res judicata.

Will I get my filing fees back after discontinuance?

No. The New York filing fee schedule treats fees as nonrefundable once the case is opened, regardless of how it ends.

Do counterclaims survive a plaintiff’s discontinuance?

Yes. Under CPLR 3217(a)(2), counterclaims and cross-claims remain pending unless the stipulation expressly discontinues them too.

Can a class action be discontinued by stipulation alone?

No. CPLR 908 requires court approval and notice to class members before any class action can be voluntarily discontinued.

Does a voluntary discontinuance toll the statute of limitations?

No. CPLR 205(a) explicitly excludes voluntary dismissals from the six-month savings period that applies to involuntary terminations.

Can I file the stipulation by email or fax?

No. Most New York courts require either NYSCEF upload through the e-filing portal or in-person paper filing at the County Clerk’s office.

Does a stipulation need court approval if a minor is involved?

Yes. CPLR 1207 requires an infant compromise order, signed by a judge, before any settlement or discontinuance involving a minor becomes effective.

Can the parties keep the settlement amount confidential?

Yes. The stipulation itself usually contains no dollar figures, and the parties can sign a separate confidential settlement agreement outside the public docket.

Is there a deadline to file the stipulation after settlement?

No. CPLR 3217(a)(2) allows filing at any time before the case is submitted to the court or jury, although prompt filing avoids status conference notices.