Can LLC Members Really Be Paid As Employees? – It Depends, But Avoid This Mistake + FAQs

Confused about whether LLC members can be employees? You’re not alone.

According to recent business data, over 40% of LLC owners misclassify their payments, risking IRS penalties and tax inefficiencies. Getting this right is crucial for both legal compliance and optimizing your taxes.

LLC Owners on Payroll: Can You Pay Yourself a Salary?

The Short Answer: In most cases, no – by default, an LLC member (owner) cannot be treated as a W-2 employee of their own LLC. However, there are important exceptions. With the right tax elections, an LLC owner can wear an employee hat. It all comes down to how your LLC is classified for tax purposes.

• Default Federal Rules: The IRS does not consider owners of a standard LLC to be employees. A single-member LLC is a “disregarded entity,” taxed like a sole proprietorship, and a multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership. In both situations, the owners are self-employed in the eyes of the IRS, not employees. You generally cannot put yourself on payroll or receive a W-2 from the LLC under these default classifications. Instead, you pay yourself through owner’s draws or distributions of profit.

• Why Not? Under federal law, you can’t be both an employer and an employee of the same entity when it’s taxed as a partnership or sole proprietorship. The IRS has long held that a partner (or LLC member) providing services cannot be treated as an employee for tax purposes. All profit you earn from the business is simply your self-employment income, not a wage.

• The Big Exception – Electing Corporate Status: If your LLC elects to be taxed as a corporation, the game changes. LLCs can file a form to be taxed as either an S Corporation or a C Corporation. Once this election is made, the IRS views the company as a separate taxable entity, and the owners can indeed be employees on the payroll. In an LLC taxed as a corporation, members who work in the business become W-2 employees (often termed owner-employees or shareholder-employees). They receive a salary with taxes withheld, just like any other employee, and can also take additional profit as dividends or distributions.

Single-Member vs. Multi-Member Differences: Both single-member and multi-member LLCs follow the above principles, but here’s the nuance:

• Single-Member LLC (Default: Sole Proprietorship) – You cannot pay yourself a salary or hourly wage as an “employee.” All the LLC’s profit is already yours and you pay income tax (and self-employment tax) on it. You take money out by simply writing yourself a check or transferring funds (an owner’s draw). If you want to be on payroll, the only way is to elect S corp or C corp taxation for your LLC. For example, Jane is the sole owner of an LLC consulting business. By default, she can’t issue herself a W-2; she just withdraws profits. If Jane elects S corp status, she could then become an employee of her own LLC and pay herself a salary (more on that later).

• Multi-Member LLC (Default: Partnership) – The IRS treats multiple-owner LLCs like a partnership. That means no member can be a W-2 employee of the LLC under default rules. Instead, members receive their share of profits as distributions, and if the LLC agreement allows, they might get guaranteed payments (a fixed payment to a member, similar to a salary substitute, but still not treated as W-2 wages). To have members on payroll, again the LLC would need to elect S corp or C corp taxation. For instance, suppose Bob and Carol co-own an LLC bakery. In default partnership mode, Bob and Carol can’t draw W-2 salaries from the business. They split profits per their ownership (and perhaps give Carol a larger guaranteed payment if she manages the shop daily). If they instead elect S corporation taxation, Bob and Carol could each become employees of the LLC and receive regular paychecks.

Bottom Line: By default, LLC members are owners, not employees. You generally pay yourself from an LLC through profit distributions (or draws/guaranteed payments), not through a paycheck. However, by opting for S corp or C corp status, an LLC’s members can be paid as employees, subject to additional rules. Next, we’ll explore the pitfalls to avoid in navigating these options.

🚫 Avoid These Common Pitfalls When Paying Yourself

Even savvy business owners can slip up when figuring out how to compensate themselves from an LLC. Here are some costly mistakes and misunderstandings to avoid:

1. Paying Yourself as an Employee Without the Right Election: The #1 mistake is treating yourself as a W-2 employee when your LLC is still taxed as a sole proprietorship or partnership. Example Pitfall: A single-member LLC owner runs payroll for themselves and issues a W-2 at year-end without electing S corp status. This is a misclassification; the IRS could reject the W-2 and recharacterize those payments as draws, causing headaches with taxes already withheld. Avoid this by remembering: unless you’ve elected corporate taxation, you are not an employee of your LLC.

2. Skipping Payroll When You Are Required: The opposite mistake also happens. Some LLCs do elect S corporation status (to save on taxes) but then fail to actually run a payroll for the owner. Owners might be tempted to take all the money out as distributions and not give themselves a salary. This is not allowed – the IRS expects “reasonable compensation” for any owner-employee in an S corp. If you don’t pay yourself a real salary, you could face back taxes and penalties. Best practice: if your LLC is an S corp, put yourself on a regular payroll at a market-rate salary before taking extra profit draws.

3. Misclassifying Draws or Distributions as Expenses: Remember that an owner’s draw or profit distribution from an LLC is not a wage and not a business expense. It’s a transfer of equity. A common bookkeeping mistake is recording owner withdrawals as a payroll expense or “salary” on the books. This misrepresentation can mess up your financial records and tax filings. Keep it clear: draws are taken from after-tax profits and don’t reduce business income on the tax return (in a default LLC). Only if you are legitimately on payroll (in an S/C corp scenario) should you record an expense for salary.

4. Commingling Personal and Business Funds: LLC owners sometimes pay personal bills directly from the business account or vice versa, thinking “it’s my money anyway.” This is risky. Not only can it weaken your liability protection (piercing the corporate veil), it also complicates the distinction between an owner’s draw vs. a business expense. To avoid trouble: keep a clear line—pay yourself properly (via a documented draw, distribution, or payroll check) and then use the money personally, rather than directly using business funds for personal expenses.

5. Ignoring Tax Withholding & Estimated Taxes: If you are not on payroll, the LLC isn’t withholding taxes for you. Many new LLC owners forget that self-employment taxes and income taxes still apply to their earnings. If you take draws, you must set aside and pay quarterly estimated taxes on that income. Conversely, if you are on payroll (after a corp election), ensure you’re handling withholding, FICA (Social Security & Medicare taxes), and any state payroll taxes for your own paycheck. Avoid surprises: plan for these tax payments so you don’t end up with a big IRS bill or penalties at year-end.

By steering clear of these pitfalls, you’ll maintain compliance and maximize the benefits of your LLC structure. Next, let’s clarify some key terms and concepts that frequently come up when discussing LLC members and employment status.

Key Terms Explained: LLC, Member, Self-Employment Tax & More 📖

Understanding the terminology is half the battle. Here are essential terms and concepts related to LLCs and paying yourself, explained in plain English:

• Limited Liability Company (LLC): A flexible business structure that provides personal liability protection to owners (members). For tax purposes, an LLC is not a default tax class – it can be a disregarded entity, partnership, or elect to be taxed as a corporation. LLCs are popular for their simplicity and versatility.

• Member: An owner of an LLC. Single-member LLCs have one owner; multi-member LLCs have two or more. “Member” is the LLC equivalent of a partner or shareholder. Members can be individuals or other companies.

• Disregarded Entity: How the IRS views a single-member LLC by default – essentially “ignoring” the LLC as separate from its owner for tax filing. The single owner reports all income/expenses on their personal tax return (Schedule C, etc.), as if the business were a sole proprietorship. In this state, you and the business are one tax-paying unit.

• Partnership (for tax purposes): The default tax classification for an LLC with multiple owners. The LLC doesn’t pay income tax itself; instead, it files an information return (Form 1065) and passes through profits to owners via Schedule K-1. Each member pays tax on their share. Importantly, partners (LLC members) are not employees under this setup.

• Pass-Through Taxation: A system where business profits “pass through” to the owners’ personal tax returns, avoiding any entity-level income tax. LLCs (unless taxed as C corps) are pass-through entities. The owners pay the tax on profits (whether or not the money is distributed to them), and the LLC itself generally does not pay income tax as a separate entity.

• Self-Employment Tax: The combined Social Security and Medicare tax that self-employed individuals must pay on their earnings. It’s roughly 15.3% of net income (up to certain limits for Social Security). LLC members in a default tax status are subject to self-employment tax on their share of the business income, since they’re considered self-employed. (In a traditional job, these are the payroll taxes split between employer and employee; in self-employment, you pay both halves).

• Payroll Taxes: Taxes tied to wages paid to employees, including Social Security, Medicare (FICA taxes), federal and state income tax withholding, and federal/state unemployment taxes. If an LLC member becomes an employee (through a corp election), the LLC must withhold and pay these taxes on the member’s salary like any employer would. Note: If you’re not an employee, you won’t have payroll withholdings – you’ll handle taxes through self-employment tax and quarterly estimates instead.

• Owner’s Draw (Owner Distribution): A non-salary withdrawal of profits by an LLC owner. In a single-member or partnership LLC, taking an owner’s draw is how you pay yourself. This is simply transferring money from the business account to the owner’s personal account. Draws are not taxed at the time of withdrawal (they’re post-tax profit), and they are not a deductible business expense. They also don’t trigger withholding like a paycheck would.

• Guaranteed Payment: A term in partnership taxation for payments to a partner (or LLC member in a multi-member LLC) that are made regardless of the partnership’s profit. It’s like a salary substitute for active partners. For example, an LLC’s operating agreement might guarantee a member $50,000 a year for their management role, even if profits are low. Guaranteed payments are deductible to the partnership and taxable to the recipient as ordinary income, and they are subject to self-employment tax. They are not wages (no W-2 is issued), but they ensure a member gets compensated for work before profits are split.

• S Corporation (S Corp): A special corporate tax status (available to small businesses meeting certain criteria) that an LLC can elect by filing Form 2553 with the IRS. An S corp doesn’t pay federal income tax at the entity level (it’s pass-through to owners), but owners who work for the business must be treated as employees. In an LLC taxed as an S corp, the owner-members pay themselves a salary (with payroll taxes) for their labor, and any remaining profit is distributed as passive income (which is not subject to self-employment tax). S corps come with rules (limited number of shareholders, one class of stock, U.S. residents/citizens only, etc.), but they can provide tax savings on self-employment taxes if done correctly.

• C Corporation (C Corp): The standard corporate tax classification. An LLC can elect to be taxed as a C corporation by filing Form 8832. A C corp is a separate taxpaying entity (it pays corporate income tax on its profits). Owners (shareholders) can work as employees and receive salaries. Profits can also be paid out as dividends to shareholders. Be mindful of double taxation: salaries are deductible to the corporation, but profits after salaries are taxed at the corporate level, then dividends are taxed again on the owner’s personal return. C corp status is less common for small LLCs unless there’s a specific reason (like seeking outside investment or fringe benefit optimization).

• Reasonable Compensation: An IRS requirement for S corporation owner-employees. It means the salary you pay yourself from an S corp (or an LLC taxed as S corp) must be market rate for the work you do. You can’t pay yourself $5,000 a year if similar CEOs or managers earn $80,000 – the IRS would see that as an attempt to avoid taxes. If your LLC is paying members as employees under S corp rules, ensure the wages are in line with what you’d pay someone else to do the job. Unreasonably low salaries are a red flag that can trigger audits and reclassification of distributions as wages.

Now that we’ve clarified these key concepts, let’s look at some concrete scenarios of how LLC members get paid under different setups.

How It Works: Examples of Paying LLC Members in Different Scenarios

Understanding rules is easier with examples. Below are a few real-world style scenarios illustrating how LLC owners pay themselves (and get taxed) as non-employees vs. employees:

Example 1: Alice – Single-Member LLC (Default Taxation)

Scenario: Alice is the sole owner of Alice’s Art Design LLC, with no special tax elections. Her LLC is a one-woman show, and it earned a net profit of $80,000 this year.

How Alice Pays Herself: Because Alice’s LLC is a single-member LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship, she does not take a formal salary. Instead, Alice can draw from the profits at will. For instance, she might transfer $5,000 each month from the business account to her personal account to cover her living expenses, totaling $60,000 for the year. These transfers are owner’s draws.

Tax Outcome: Alice will report the full $80,000 of business profit on her personal tax return (Schedule C). The $60,000 she drew is not separately taxed or deducted – it’s part of that profit. She will pay income tax on $80k, and also around $80k * 15.3% in self-employment taxes (~$12,240) for Social Security and Medicare. The timing of her draws doesn’t affect her taxes (even the $20k she left in the business is still taxed as her income). She doesn’t receive a W-2, and no taxes were withheld on her draws, so Alice must ensure she paid enough in quarterly estimates to cover the tax due.

Key Point: Alice cannot treat that $60k she took out as a “salary” – it’s just her taking her own money. If she mistakenly tried to put herself on payroll, it would be improper. To become an actual employee of her business, she’d need to have the LLC elect S corp or C corp status.

Example 2: Bob & Carol – Multi-Member LLC (Partnership Taxation)

Scenario: Bob and Carol co-founded B&C Bakers LLC, a bakery with two members (each owns 50%). The LLC is taxed as a partnership. They agreed Bob manages the storefront full-time while Carol handles special orders on the side.

How They Pay Themselves: Under the default partnership setup, Bob and Carol do not take W-2 salaries. Instead, they receive distributions of profit according to their ownership or as decided in the operating agreement. Let’s say in a given year the bakery’s profit (after expenses) is $100,000. By default 50/50 ownership, each is entitled to $50,000. They might periodically draw out a portion of that (e.g. monthly draws of $4,000 each, leaving some cash for bakery operations).

Guaranteed Payment Example: Because Bob works more in the day-to-day business, Bob and Carol have a clause in their LLC agreement giving Bob a guaranteed payment of $20,000 per year for his managerial role off the top of profits. This ensures Bob is compensated for the extra hours he puts in. That $20,000 is paid to Bob throughout the year (similar to a salary advance from profits). The remaining profit ($80,000) is then split 50/50 – so Bob gets $40,000 + $20,000 guaranteed = $60,000 total, and Carol gets $40,000.

Tax Outcome: The LLC files a partnership tax return (Form 1065) and issues each of Bob and Carol a K-1 showing their share of income. Bob’s K-1 will show $60k, Carol’s $40k. They each report this on their personal taxes and pay income tax accordingly. Additionally, because they are active members, both Bob and Carol must pay self-employment tax on their shares ($60k and $40k). The $20k guaranteed payment to Bob is treated like ordinary income to him (and a business expense for the LLC, reducing the profit pool). Importantly, neither Bob nor Carol was on payroll as an “employee,” and the LLC did not withhold any taxes from the distributions or issue W-2s. They must cover their own Medicare/Social Security via self-employment tax.

Key Point: Even though Bob received a steady payment for his work, it’s not a formal salary – it’s a guaranteed payment. B&C Bakers LLC cannot simply decide to call Bob an employee and start issuing a paycheck without changing tax status. To have them as employees, they’d need to elect corporate taxation.

Example 3: Dana – LLC Electing S Corporation (Owner as Employee)

Scenario: Dana is the 100% owner of TechNova LLC. After talking with her CPA, she elects to have TechNova taxed as an S corporation starting this year to optimize taxes. The business makes about $150,000 in annual profit, and Dana is very active in it.

How Dana Pays Herself: Now that TechNova LLC is an S corp for tax purposes, Dana must put herself on the company’s payroll as an employee. Based on industry standards for her role, Dana decides on a reasonable salary of $70,000 per year for her work as the CEO/consultant. The LLC uses a payroll service, and Dana receives biweekly paychecks that total $70k by year-end, with income tax, Social Security, and Medicare taxes withheld just like any employee. The remaining profit of $80,000 ($150k minus her $70k salary and any other expenses) is left in the company to distribute as an S corp dividend (also called a distribution to owner).

Throughout the year, Dana also takes that $80,000 out in one or more distribution payments (or she could leave some in the business – either way it passes through to her for tax).

Tax Outcome: TechNova LLC (as an S corp) files an 1120-S tax return and gives Dana a K-1 for the $80,000 of business profit (the portion beyond her salary). Dana’s taxes look like this:

• She gets a W-2 for the $70k salary. She and the company have each paid their share of payroll taxes on that $70k (around $5,355 from her and $5,355 from the company for Social Security/Medicare, for example). She’ll report this W-2 income on her 1040, just like if she worked for someone else.
• The $80,000 profit is reported to her via the K-1. She will pay income tax on that $80k, but no self-employment tax on it, because S corp distributions are not subject to Social Security/Medicare taxes. This is where the tax savings come in: had Dana been a sole proprietor, the entire $150k would face self-employment tax. By using the S corp, only the $70k salary was subject to those taxes. The $80k distribution avoids the 15.3% self-employment tax, potentially saving Dana over $12,000 in taxes.
• Important: Dana had to ensure $70k was a fair salary. If she tried to pay herself only $20k salary and call $130k a distribution, the IRS would likely consider $20k unreasonably low for the work and reclassify more of that distribution as wages (charging back payroll taxes).

Key Point: With the S corp structure, Dana successfully became an employee of her own LLC and reaped a tax benefit. But she also incurred new responsibilities: running payroll, filing payroll tax returns, and adhering to the reasonable compensation rule. This path is fantastic for some businesses but requires due diligence.

These examples highlight how the method of paying yourself differs dramatically based on your LLC’s tax classification. Next, we will ground these practices in the official rules and laws that govern them, and note any state-level variations to keep in mind.

IRS Rules & Legal Framework 📜

Understanding the legal underpinning helps reinforce why these rules exist. Let’s break down the federal laws first, and then touch on state nuances that might affect LLC owner compensation.

Federal Law: Why Most LLC Members Aren’t Employees

At the federal level, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has clear guidelines on business entity taxation and what that means for owners’ employment status. Here are the key points of law and IRS policy:

• Default Tax Classification (Treasury Regulation & IRS Code): By default, a single-member LLC is ignored for federal tax (treated as sole prop), and a multi-member LLC is a partnership (per IRS “check-the-box” regulations). This is why we say LLCs have “flexible” taxation – you choose by election if not default. Under these default statuses, owners are treated as self-employed individuals, not employees. The legal rationale is that you can’t be your own employer in a pass-through entity; instead, your earnings are subject to self-employment tax under the Self-Employment Contributions Act (SECA).

• IRS Rulings (Partners = Self-Employed): The IRS has long-standing rulings, such as Revenue Ruling 69-184, that assert a partner cannot be an employee of the same partnership. LLC members in a multi-member LLC are by extension considered partners for tax. So, federal law prohibits simultaneously being a partner (owner) and a W-2 employee in the same partnership/LLC. All compensation for services in that context should be through distributions or guaranteed payments, not wages.

• Electing Corporate Status (Form 8832 or 2553): The Internal Revenue Code allows LLCs to elect to be taxed as a corporation. By filing Form 8832, an LLC can choose to be taxed under subchapter C (C corporation) or, if eligible, by filing Form 2553 it can elect subchapter S (S corporation). Once this election is effective, the LLC is no longer taxed as a disregarded entity/partnership. Legally, this transforms how owner compensation is treated. The owners for tax purposes become shareholders (and if working, employee-shareholders). There’s no rule prohibiting an owner from being an employee of a corporation (even a 100% owner can be on payroll). In fact, the law requires that any owner who is actively working in an S corp must be on payroll as an employee receiving reasonable wages. This is supported by numerous IRS enforcement actions and tax court cases that re-characterize distributions as wages when owners tried to avoid payroll.

• Employment Taxes & Reporting: If an LLC member becomes an employee through corporate taxation, federal law mandates all the usual employer obligations: withholding federal income tax, withholding and paying FICA taxes, and paying federal unemployment (FUTA) tax on the wages. They will receive a W-2 at year-end. The IRS and Social Security Administration treat them no differently than any other employee in terms of tax reporting. On the flip side, if the LLC member is not an employee (default scenario), their earnings are reported on Schedule C or K-1 and they pay self-employment tax via Schedule SE. No W-2 or payroll tax deposits are required for their own draws.

• Why Become an Employee at All? One might wonder, why would an LLC owner want to be an employee given the added paperwork? The main legal/tax reason is the potential tax savings on self-employment taxes (in an S corp) and the ability to participate in certain benefit plans or credits. For instance, as an employee, an owner could potentially have the company contribute to a 401(k) or pay health insurance premiums pre-tax (though S corp >2% owners have special rules for benefits). In a C corp scenario, owners on payroll can fully deduct fringe benefits as corporate expenses (C corps can offer owner-employees tax-free benefits like health insurance, group life, etc., which are harder to do in pass-through form). These advantages are recognized in tax regulations, which is why S and C corps exist as options. The trade-off is compliance with the corporate tax rules.

• Tax Court and IRS Scrutiny: It’s worth noting that the IRS keeps a close eye on S corporations for the issue of owner compensation. There have been cases where an LLC taxed as S corp paid zero or very low wages to the owner and high distributions, and the IRS adjusted the taxes, often winning in court. So, the legal framework requires a balance: you can minimize taxes, but you must follow the rules (i.e. pay yourself a fair salary for actual work performed).

In summary, federal law sets the baseline: by default, no employee status for owners, unless you deliberately opt into a system that allows it (corporate taxation). Always consider IRS guidelines on what’s permissible to avoid reclassification or penalties.

State Law Nuances: Does State Law Differ?

For the most part, states follow the federal classification of your LLC when it comes to income tax. If your LLC is treated as a partnership federally, your state will also treat it as such for state income tax, and similarly for S corp or C corp. However, there are some state-level considerations to keep in mind:

• State Taxes and Compliance: If you elect S corp status, be aware that not all states recognize the S corp (a few tax you like a C corp at state level, or have additional S corp requirements). Most states, however, mirror the federal treatment. So if you’re an employee of your LLC for federal, you’ll also be an employee for state tax purposes, meaning state income tax withholding and state unemployment insurance contributions on your wages. Always register with your state’s labor or taxation department once you start payroll for yourself.

• Unemployment Insurance for Owners: Some states may exempt LLC members (especially those with substantial ownership, like >10% or >50%) from being required to pay state unemployment insurance on themselves, even if they’re on payroll. This is a nuance in state labor law: for example, a state might not require unemployment tax for a family-owned business’s owner-employee, since that owner is unlikely to ever claim unemployment benefits. On the flip side, other states might allow an owner to voluntarily opt into unemployment coverage. It’s worth checking your state’s rules. If exempt, you could potentially skip paying into unemployment for your own wages, saving a bit, but you also wouldn’t be eligible for unemployment checks if the business closes or you remove yourself from payroll.

• Workers’ Compensation: Similar to unemployment, workers’ comp insurance rules vary by state for business owners. In some states, LLC members (especially if they are the only owners) can opt out of workers’ comp coverage, since they are owners rather than traditional employees. In others, if you’re on payroll, you might be required or able to include/exclude yourself from coverage. This doesn’t affect your ability to be paid as an employee, but it’s a compliance point if you do become an employee of your LLC.

• State LLC Laws: It’s important to note that whether you can be an “employee” of your LLC for legal purposes (outside of tax) might depend on state LLC statutes. Generally, there’s no prohibition on an owner also having an employment contract or role in the company. The distinction is mostly tax-driven. Some states define that managers of an LLC (in a manager-managed LLC) can receive compensation, but again typically as guaranteed payments or distributions unless taxed as a corporation.

• Community Property Nuance: In community property states (like California, Texas, etc.), a husband and wife who jointly own a LLC can choose to treat it as a single-member disregarded entity for federal tax (if they file jointly) or a partnership. This is a special case. It doesn’t directly change the rule about employees – even in that case, they wouldn’t be employees unless a corp election is made. But it’s a unique state-related consideration for how an LLC is classified by the IRS due to state marital property law.

In conclusion, while federal law is the main driver of whether you as an LLC member can be paid as an employee, do check your state’s regulations when you set up payroll or choose a tax status. State tax rates, additional LLC fees (some states charge an LLC franchise tax or annual fee that might differ if you’re taxed as a corp), and employment-related rules can influence the overall strategy. Always consult with a tax professional or business attorney familiar with your state to ensure you’re compliant on all levels.

Now that we’ve covered rules and regulations, let’s compare the different structures side-by-side to solidify our understanding of how each option works in practice.

Salary vs. Draw: Comparing LLC Payment Structures

LLC owners have several ways to get paid, depending on the structure. Here’s a comparison of four common setups for an LLC member’s compensation:

LLC Tax Status	Single-Member LLC<br>(Default: Disregarded)	Multi-Member LLC<br>(Default: Partnership)	LLC taxed as S Corp	LLC taxed as C Corp
Owner’s role (for taxes)	Sole proprietor (one and the same as owner)	Partner in a partnership	Shareholder-employee (owner and employee)	Shareholder-employee (owner and employee)
Can owner be a W-2 employee?	No. The owner cannot be on payroll as an employee under default status.	No. Members cannot receive W-2 wages (treated as partners, not employees).	Yes. Owner who works in the business must be on payroll and gets a W-2 with salary.	Yes. Owners can work as employees of the company and receive W-2 wages.
How does the owner get paid?	Owner’s draw – withdraw profits from the business as needed.	Distributions of profit according to ownership share; optionally guaranteed payments for services to the LLC.	Salary through regular payroll (plus additional distributions of remaining profit).	Salary through payroll for services; potentially dividends (share of profits) as a shareholder.
Taxes on earnings	All business profit is reported on owner’s personal tax return. Self-employment tax (15.3%) applies to the profit, since it’s self-employment income.	All profit passes to members’ personal tax returns. Active members pay self-employment tax on their share of income (including any guaranteed payments).	Two parts: Salary is subject to income tax and payroll taxes (Social Security/Medicare split between employee and employer). The remaining profit distribution is subject to income tax for the owner but not self-employment tax.	Two levels: Salary is taxed as regular employment income (with withholding and payroll taxes). The corporation’s profits are taxed at the corporate level first. If paid out as dividends to owners, those dividends are taxed again on the owner’s personal return (but not subject to payroll or self-employment tax).
Tax forms & reporting	Income and expenses filed on Schedule C (Form 1040). No W-2 for owner; must file Schedule SE for self-employment tax.	Files a partnership return Form 1065; each member gets a K-1. No W-2s for members; members use K-1 to report income and pay SE tax.	Files Form 1120-S. Owner gets a W-2 for salary and a K-1 for their share of any remaining profit. Must file quarterly payroll reports (941s, state equivalents) for the salary.	Files Form 1120 (corporate tax return). Owner gets a W-2 for any salary. If dividends are issued, Form 1099-DIV may be used. Payroll filings required for any wages.
Pros	Simplicity: Easy to administer, no separate corporate tax filings. No need to process payroll for the owner. Full control over taking draws.	Flexibility: Can allocate profits in custom ways via the operating agreement. Still relatively simple admin. No owner payroll obligations.	Tax savings potential: Can reduce self-employment tax by splitting income into salary + distributions. Owners on payroll can contribute to retirement plans as employees. Still pass-through (no double tax).	Benefits and growth: Owners can get full employee benefits (fringe benefits often fully deductible). Ability to retain profits in the company at a 21% federal tax rate. Easier to bring in investors with stock.
Cons	Tax burden: Owner pays self-employment tax on all earnings. No opportunity to reduce Social Security/Medicare tax. Also, draws require discipline to pay estimated taxes since no withholding.	Tax burden: Active members pay self-employment tax on full share. Can’t treat income as salary, so limited strategies to reduce SE tax. Managing multiple owners’ distributions requires good records.	More complexity: Requires running a payroll (or paying a service) and additional tax forms. Must adhere to S corp rules (limits on number/type of owners, one class of stock). Reasonable salary rule scrutiny. Some benefits (like certain insurance) aren’t tax-free for >2% owner.	Double taxation: Profits taxed at corporate level and again if distributed as dividends. More complex accounting. Not advantageous for small businesses in most cases due to potential higher total tax, unless profits are reinvested or specific fringe benefit goals.

As the table shows, each structure has trade-offs. Most small LLCs start as default pass-throughs (sole prop or partnership) because of the simplicity. Electing S Corp can save money on taxes once the profit is high enough to justify the added paperwork – it’s a popular strategy when an LLC’s net income grows beyond, say, ~$40,000-50,000, making the self-employment tax hit significant. C Corps are less common for LLCs unless you plan to seek investors or keep profits in the business for expansion (and you’re okay with the double tax on any payouts).

Which Option is Best? It depends on your business’s specifics:

• If you’re a solo freelancer or side-hustler making modest income, staying as a single-member LLC (disregarded) might be perfectly fine – simple and no fuss.
• If you have partners, you’ll be default as a partnership; you might stick with that if you’re okay paying self-employment tax and want minimal complexity. Just ensure you structure distributions and any guaranteed payments properly among yourselves.
• If you’re earning significant profits and essentially paying a lot in self-employment tax, looking into an S corp election could be wise – just be ready to pay yourself a fair salary and handle payroll. Many LLC owners convert to S corps as their businesses mature to take advantage of this.
• C corp taxation might make sense if you plan to retain earnings for a while (so you avoid the second layer tax until later) or if you want to maximize deductions of certain benefits (like full health insurance coverage for you and your family paid by the company, which in an S corp would be partly added to your W-2). C corp could also be needed if you’re bringing on investors who prefer stock ownership. But remember, you can also start as an LLC and later convert to a corporation or vice versa as needs change.

The good news is LLCs are very flexible – you’re never completely locked in. Just be sure to follow the formal process (and timing) for any tax classification changes, and consult a tax advisor to run the numbers for your situation.

---

Before we wrap up, let’s tackle some frequently asked questions on this topic:

FAQ: LLC Members and Employee Pay

Q: Can a single-member LLC owner be on the company’s payroll?
A: Not by default. A single-member LLC owner can only be on payroll if the LLC elects S corp or C corp taxation. Otherwise, the owner takes profits as draws, not via payroll.

Q: Do LLC members pay self-employment tax on their earnings?
A: Yes – in a default-taxed LLC, all active members pay self-employment tax (15.3%) on their share of profits (including guaranteed payments). In an S corp setup, only the salary portion faces those taxes.

Q: Can an LLC issue a W-2 to an owner?
A: Only if the LLC is taxed as a corporation. If it’s taxed as a partnership or sole proprietorship, it should not issue a W-2 to a member. The member’s income is reported on their personal return via Schedule C or K-1 instead.

Q: What’s the best way to pay yourself in an LLC to save on taxes?
A: For many profitable businesses, electing S corp status and taking a reasonable salary can reduce self-employment taxes. However, if profits are low or you want simplicity, sticking with the default (and just taking draws) might be best.

Q: What are guaranteed payments in an LLC?
A: Guaranteed payments are pre-agreed amounts paid to an LLC member (in a multi-member LLC taxed as a partnership) for their services or capital. They act like a salary substitute, ensuring that member is compensated regardless of profit levels. They’re taxed as ordinary income to the recipient (and subject to self-employment tax) but are not treated as W-2 wages.

Q: Why would an LLC choose to be taxed as an S corporation?
A: Mainly to reduce the self-employment tax burden on owners’ income. By paying part of the earnings as salary and the rest as distribution not subject to SE tax, owners can potentially save thousands in Medicare/Social Security taxes. It also formalizes the owner’s role as an employee, which can help with retirement plans and other benefits.

Q: Can I change my LLC’s tax status later?
A: Yes. An LLC can file to change its classification (for example, from disregarded/partnership to S corp) by submitting the appropriate IRS forms, typically effective at the start of a tax year. Make sure to meet deadlines and criteria for the election (e.g., S corp election generally due by March 15 for the year you want it to take effect). It’s wise to consult a tax professional before switching, to weigh pros and cons.